-
Opinion
After Harold
The ‘Harold rumour’ rarely goes away.
Last time round WPP was rumoured to be looking at buying Mitchell Communication Group. On another occasion one of the trade magazines hoaxed a rival into reporting that Telstra was the buyer.
This time, the rumour appears to have a great deal more substance. Read more »
Intelligent TV – the next big thing?
I was, I must confess, mistaken about last night’s Gruen Nation. Read more »
Masterchef: Homophobic? No. Racist? No. Ageist? Maybe
In this guest posting, Tactical TV’s Tony Richardson argues that Masterchef shows Australian TV audiences are ready for multiculturalism but not older faces
When the popularity of a TV show bumps the prime minister and the leader of the opposition to an earlier time slot, you know you have a phenomenon. Read more »
Bad enough the SMH iPad app is just a PDF, forcing a print subscription is insane
So yesterday Fairfax launched its Sydney Morning Herald iPad app. The strategy – designed to shore up print – and the execution – already derided by users as a “glorifed PDF reader” – are both laughable.
If there were ever doubts that Fairfax is two companies pulling in different directions, then the handling of the iPad app dispels them. Read more »
Is a kettle boiling a good ad?
So would you watch a kettle boiling? The weekend magazines carriedied an unusual ad.It was a plain, unbranded address for the url Life is too short.com.au. Read more »
Guest post: Why Sensis believes in the cause
After Mumbrella criticised the Facebook campaign by Sensis to give socks to the homeless, we invited the brand to explain its thinking. In this guest posting, Sensis communications manager Danielle Horan explains the background to the idea
The debate about the intention behind the Sensis 1234 Warm Up campaign certainly unearthed a range of differing opinions. Read more »
Hungry Jack’s – something to sing about
I often enjoy giving the Hungry Jack’s ads a kicking, so it’s good to see a new one where there’s an interesting idea. Read more »
The big election question
As an occasional media commentator, I’m sometimes asked: ‘Tell me Tim. Given that politicians want to engage the electorate beyond the hardcore politics junkies, would it be a good idea to schedule the leaders’ debate at the exact same time as the final of Masterchef, arguably Australia’s favourite TV programme and likely to be the most watched show of the year?” Read more »
Why this is NOT the Twitter election
If you read the last few days’ papers, you would think that the Twitterati will decide the outcome of the election. Read more »
Paging the fun police
While any brand has to worry about the legal implications of running a contest, there does come a point where the entire thing looks so unappealing it may be worth going back to the drawing board. Read more »
Oh PETA
This ad is a tough watch.
If you don’t want to see seals being clubbed, then don’t watch. Read more »
Sensis – social responsibility isn’t about patronising the needy about their socks
I wish I could put my finger on what it is that makes this social issues campaign for Sensis feel so icky: Read more »
Old Spice: Best use of social media yet?
Today has been a good day. You know those very rare moments where you see an advertising idea and you can recognise not only how good it is, but how it’s going to inspire other great work? What Old Spice did next is one of those moments.It combines great advertising, great writing, a huge PR idea and excellent use of social media as a two-way channel. Read more »
If that’s how paywalls work then we’re utterly flipping screwed
So tonight, for the first time, I went behind Fairfax Media’s pay wall.
Based on that experience, if the future of journalism is paid content then every one of us working hacks is utterly screwed. Read more »
Media Watch picks an odd target
I’ve got a nasty feeling I’ve finally gone native.
Much like Stockholm Syndrome where kidnap victims come to adore their captors, journalists have always been susceptible to a similar syndrome. Read more »
Adland needs its own stimulus package says Howcroft
The Australian advertising industry deserves a government stimulus package of its own, claims GPY&R Melbourne boss Russel Howcroft.
The Gruen Transfer panellist tells the current edition of AdNews: “We need some advertiser-friendly policies to assist with demand generation.” He adds: “It makes sense to assist advertisers with generating demand by stimulating media expenditure.”
Citing the tax rebate given by the government to the film industry, he concedes: “Yes, there’s self-interest in me saying that, but it is based on ensuring we’ve got a thriving media marketplace, and generating demand via advertising.”
-
Follow Us
-
Email Newsletter
THE MUMBO REPORT
-
In today’s Mumbo Report from Studio 33:
- AWARD chairman Craig Davis on the importance of being a dysfunctional creative;
- Good Weekend columnist Mark Dapin on why Alan Jones is the most powerful person in Australian media.


-
Latest News
- Photon Group: negotiations are 'complex, fluid and interdependent'
- Mitchells board recommends $363m Aegis deal
- Four fight it out for ad of the month
- Aegis 'in advanced talks' to buy Mitchells
- Mumbo Report: AWARD'S Craig Davis and Mark Dapin on Alan Jones
- Gruen Nation leads ABC1 to massive night
- Sphere Agency wins Melbourne Heart FC
- Honda Jazz asks: How many hipsters can you fit in a car?
Dr Mumbo
-
Latest Comments
- Tom on Gruen Nation leads ABC1 to massive night
- Anonymous on Four fight it out for ad of the month
- Anonymous on Photon Group: negotiations are ‘complex, fluid and interdependent’
- Carli on Four fight it out for ad of the month
- Chris Walton on Gruen Nation leads ABC1 to massive night
- belieber on Ten’s next talent spectacular: Don’t Stop Believing
- Clara on Sphere Agency wins Melbourne Heart FC
- Tamz on Intelligent TV – the next big thing?
Latest Jobs- Digital Account Director (Award Winning Agency) - Sydney
- Delivery Manager, Viva9 - Sydney / Darlinghurst
- Arts / Sub-editor - Time Out Sydney - Sydney
- SEM Campaign Manager - Sydney CBD
- Web Developer - front end - Sydney
- Sales Executive - online publishing - Balmain, Sydney
- Senior Account Director - Brand - Melbourne
- SALES EXECUTIVE - SYDNEY
- Emarketing Coordinator - Ultimo
- BDM - Carsguide - Sydney
F.Y.I.
Most Discussed
- Old Spice: Best use of social media yet?
With 114 comments - Media Watch picks an odd target
With 74 comments - Sensis - social responsibility isn't about patronising the needy about their socks
With 72 comments - Clients start to sign up for guaranteed PR model
With 71 comments - World Vision seeks the smell of Old Spice's viral success
With 65 comments - PR man promises: Media coverage or don't pay me
With 59 comments - Peter Mycock to head MySpace commercial operations
With 54 comments - Latest CommBank ad focuses on promises kept
With 53 comments
- Old Spice: Best use of social media yet?

Comments
11 May 09
9:59 am
Its a hopelessly naive rational for a advertising stimulus package. The Screen Australia rebates and funds encourage local production investment in works of potentially artistic and cultural value. Without major studios, the Australian film industry would practically disappear without the funding available in various forms since the early 80’s.
Whatever artistic or cultural value a campaign might have, advertising is obviously primarily commercial. Its simple commerce, an agency is paid to produce advertising, much like any business service.
The Ad Contrarian warns against industry hysteria warping perceptions. Advertising landscapes may change, but the principles remain the same. Mr Howcroft thinking he needs government handouts to “generate demand” is symptomatic of a dire lack of confidence to generate demand through good old fashioned ideas and smart strategies.
12 May 09
6:01 pm
Oh dear…
Ad industry is like car industry in this respect
Acknowledging marketing spends are down in some sectors, the bigger issue is that marketers are deserting the Howcroft style ad-centric paradigm for better marketing options.
Sad effort by a “big name”…
Trackbacks/Pingbacks