-
Opinion
The keyboard warrior of Twitter
In this guest post, NBN staffer Scott Rhodie writes an unofficial, personal view on his experience with a hostile Twitter critic.Last night I had a strange incident. While on Twitter I noticed someone saying that Australia’s NBN is already outdated. I wrote a small note back explaining they were incorrect.
And their response? The lovely gentleman (whose Twitter profile says: ‘Father of 5 kids, Loving Grandfather of 10 Grandchildren,and 2 Great Granddaughters. love to give heaps to Pollies and Poofters’) said to me: “Go and lick Gillards C*** out U commie Prick”
What's in a name?
In this guest post, Moensie Rossier wonders about the power of names for brands and marketers.
Brands have been having a bit of fun with names lately, not to mention a fair bit of success. Interbrand just named a headhunting firm Cloak & Dagger. And ‘Share a Coke’ showed how much power there is in a name.
The Coke campaign effectively short-circuited the usual mechanics of communication. It undoubtedly stroked people’s egos. But, I believe, its success stems from the fact that it directly and automatically affected people’s behaviour, rather than doing so indirectly by shaping attitudes.
Best ads from Super Bowl 2012
The Super Bowl is all done and a team from North America won. But as well as some sort of sporting event, it’s the world’s biggest advertising showcase. See the best of them right here… and please tell us what you think.
How to debunk media myths
In this post, UWS’s Ullrich Ecker, John Cook and Stephen Lewandowsky argue that cognitive science can help PRs form strategies in managing media misreporting.
A growing cohort of commentators has bemoaned the descent of contemporary political “debate” into a largely fact-free zone.
How about simply focusing on what consumers want?
In this guest post, Peter Mountford argues that brands should think more about what is really going on for consumers
Who here is hoping their favourite brand of toilet paper is going to be organizing a flash mob on their way home from work today?
What the Optus web copyright victory means
In this analysis first published on The Conversation, RMIT’s Marita Shelly examines the implications of Telstra’s defeat over the online rights to the AFL broadcast deal
This week’s Federal Court ruling that Optus customers are able to view sporting matches minutes after they are streamed live without breaching copyright is a landmark decision that alters our understanding of copyright law, and has significant implications for the AFL’s broadcasting rights deal.
Does Gina Rinehart’s bite of a chunk of Fairfax make her an oligarch?
In an article that first appeared in The Conversation, Mark Rolfe wonders whether the mining magnate’s move could turn Fairfax into something resembling America’s Fox network.
Australia’s richest person Gina Rinehart has moved to increase her stake in Fairfax Media, owner of The Age, Sydney Morning Herald and a number of radio stations. Rinehart has already shown her desire to play a role in public life, campaigning against former Prime Minister Kevin Rudd’s aborted mining tax. She has also demonstrated a willingness to make media investments to ensure her pro-business worldview is promulgated.
What does this latest move by Rinehart mean?
Gillard's Australia Day crisis
PM Julia Gillard’s media adviser Tony Hodges has been forced to resign over the Australia Day tent embassy debacle.
It came after it emerged he had revealed opposition leader Tony Abbott’s whereabouts, leading to both politicians being rescued by police in ugly scenes.
Mumbrella editor Tim Burrowes and advertising practitioner Jane Caro debate the topic on Weekend Sunrise’s masters of Spin segment:
The biggest cock-up I made in business
In this guest post, Chris Savage urges agency staff to live the brand.I still shudder when I think about how incredibly stupid I was when I made the biggest stuff up of my career. And then, 18 years later, I did it again. Do not make this mistake with your clients. Ever.
Hey Groupon. Thanks for fucking up email
In this guest post, Daniel Monheit warns that group deal overload is devaluing email marketingEmail marketing used to be fabulous. Back in the heady days of 2010, brands would work hard to build up well qualified databases, upon which they’d bestow carefully crafted correspondence filled with information, offers and incentives. The recipients, of course would be delighted: “Oh look! An email! From one of my favourite brands! And it’s 40 cents off at Woolies this week!”.
The staggering sway of Harold Mitchell
The Power Index today names Aegis Media chairman Harold Mitchell as the most powerful person in Melbourne. Andrew Crook profiles him.
Harold Mitchell takes pride in dispensing with the niceties. When The Power Index visited his South Melbourne private office before Christmas, fresh remains were scattered all over the boardroom table.
Share a Coke with… the moronic masses
The most-read story on Mumbrella last year, with not far off 100,000 page views, was a fairly humdrum yarn about the launch of Coca-Cola’s name-on-a-bottle campaign.The headline, “Coca-Cola puts people’s names on bottles in ‘Share a Coke’ campaign”, though hated by any self-respecting sub-editor, was loved by Google. And in rushed what can be politely described as the public.
Assumptions kill creativity
In this guest post, Gual Barwell disagrees that the sales success of the Old Spice social media campaign was overstated.Yesterday’s post from Cathie McGinn suggested the Old Spice campaign failed to connect with consumers. Based on the facts and figures, I disagree.
What Old Spice and Wieden + Kennedy has done and done phenomenally well is to create a franchise.
The SMH's readers (are wrong) editor
We are now about five months into the reign of Australia’s first readers’ editor. And I don’t think it is working.
It struck me at the time of Judy Prisk’s appointment to the Sydney Morning Herald that the fact that her boss was editor-in-chief Peter Fray was not going to be ideal if she was going to be the independent voice of the reader.
The emperor's new fragrance: Old Spice’s campaign failure
In this guest post, Cathie McGinn slays a sacred cow of 21st century marketing – the highly awarded Old Spice campaign.One of the biggest myths of recent times (by which I mean a story of great heroism and triumph we’d all like to believe but deep down know to be untrue) is the Old Spice social media campaign. It’s been much lauded and awarded as an example of outstanding content, a creative and collaborative way of connecting with consumers and driving a record increase in sales.
AWARD to review scam ads policy
The committee of AWARD, Australia’s main advertising awards body, will this week review its policy on scam ads.
The debate will take place at the AWARD committee meeting on Wednesday and follows a crackdown on scam ads in other parts of the world.
Scam ads are generally defined as ads that either did not run in paid media or were not signed off by clients. Entering a scam ad can give an agency or individual a creative an advantage over other entries because they have not had to meet a brief or go through an approval process.
This year has seen an increasing focus on scam ads globally. In the Middle East, the Dubai Lynx (organised by the Cannes Lions) saw several prizes withdrawn.
And after a fraudulent entry from DDB Brazil sparked a furore, the US-based One Show launched harsh new rules including a five year ban for agencies entering scam ads.
Last week, Cannes Lions issued a statement saying that its focus would be on individuals who transgressed rather than agencies.
Richard Maddocks, chairman of AWARD and ECD at Clemenger BBDO Sydney, told Mumbrella: “Our policy is based on individuals. Anyone found breaking the rules of entry may have work bearing their name deemed ineligible for entry for up to ten years. I’m fairly comfortable with that as a policy but because of The One Show and Cannes we will review that on Wednesday and discuss where we’re at.”
Dr Mumbo
Latest Comments
- Bill Posters on Ten to launch Breakfast on February 27
- Joel Webb on Coles to air new ‘Down, down and still’ ad tonight
- Stephen on Ten to launch Breakfast on February 27
- Sam on The keyboard warrior of Twitter
- Sam on Air NZ casts Aussies who don’t like New Zealand in reality series
- Cuthbert on Air NZ casts Aussies who don’t like New Zealand in reality series
- James on This weekend Woolworths can’t wait to give everyone an opportunity to give them a massive kicking
- Neil on Air NZ casts Aussies who don’t like New Zealand in reality series
Latest Jobs- Digital Project Manager - Melbourne
- FREELANCE Senior digital producer - 3/4 weeks - Sydney
- Digital Project Manager - Melbourne
- Marketing Manager – Optus - North Ryde, Sydney
- Film Services Coordinator - South Yarra VIC
- Marketing Specialist - Sydney
- PR: Senior Account Manager (Consumer) - $75k+ - Melbourne
- Studio Manager - Sydney
- Marketing & Customer Service - NSW Sydney
- Digital Producer - Sydney
F.Y.I.
- Adstream announces digital portfolio and asset management system
- M&C Saatchi acquires Bang PR
- Nissan to enter V8 Supercar Championships
- Fantastic Furniture goes mobile
- The Playroom launches transmedia division, makes hires
- Media Monitors Group rebrands as Sentia Media
- Circus announces second round of speakers
- Prada to launch new phone in Australia in April
Most Discussed
- Marketers told: Watch the briefs 22-year-olds at your media agencies are sending on your behalf
With 85 comments - Hey Groupon. Thanks for fucking up email
With 75 comments - Jenny Craig cancels Kyle & Jackie O sponsorship: 'We badly misjudged public perception of Sandilands'
With 68 comments - Boating industry calls agency pitch for pro-bono work
With 65 comments - Jeep erects a car on a pole
With 47 comments - Australian Ethical: we don't invest in guns, tobacco or pollution
With 46 comments - The biggest cock-up I made in business
With 45 comments - The emperor's new fragrance: Old Spice’s campaign failure
With 42 comments
- Marketers told: Watch the briefs 22-year-olds at your media agencies are sending on your behalf



Comments
19 Oct 09
4:03 pm
What about the great Australian ‘agency initiative’?
ie. Agencies paying for work to be done that the client OK’s.
Richard, how much did SEGA pay for ‘Offset the Evil’ for instance?
19 Oct 09
4:04 pm
Firstly, I agree that scammers should be outed.
The whole thing does raise the question though: do we need an ‘Open Section’ for ‘Those Ads That Didn’t Quite Make It Through The Client Approvals Process’? Anyone who’s worked on the agency side knows the best creative often gets killed off or beaten out of shape by clients very quickly, so that what the consumer sees is actually a poor excuse for what was originally pitched.
(Easy clients, I know WHY this is the case, I’m just saying…)
So, just like the proposed Steroid Olympics, who’s up for an Open Creative category? We could end up seeing some far better ads which are more representative of the creative companies’ true creative abilities as a result.
19 Oct 09
4:26 pm
Other Andrew … is that the “Client Refused Approval Proces”, or CRAP for short?
19 Oct 09
5:31 pm
@Anon,
Nice – I do love a good acronym, but I think we’d actually see a higher standard in that category, so not sure about ‘CRAP’ in this case.
I like your thinking though, so how about the ‘BACK’ Awards: Brilliants Ads Clients Killed? You could then have the BACK Edition etc etc
20 Oct 09
12:07 pm
@OtherAndrew
If you want to be demonstrate pure, unfettered, creativity, there’s a job for that. It’s called ‘artist’. If you work in advertising you are bound to a commercial imperative and that implies client approval. If it’s not approved, it’s not an ad.
21 Oct 09
5:34 pm
@Rascally,
Please don’t bring your rational, irrefutable arguments here while I’m trying to grandstand. It doesn’t help my cause.
I must agree that ‘if it’s not approved it’s not an ad’. The difference is, sometimes the reasons for the censorship/amendments are poor, and often more to do with people’s own insecurities and desire to ‘play it safe’ than whether or not it’s good for the brand.
Take the latest Toyota ‘Country Border Security’ ad (http://mumbrella.com.au/steve-.....eiled-9819). Toyota could easily have knocked this back on the basis that it scores points with a segment of their target market by poking fun at other segments. I mean really, how many Toyota 4WD owners have never had a latte? But they didn’t knock it back, and the ad is one of the best I’ve seen in years.
Gutsy clients = better creative. And by gutsy, I don’t just mean approving anything the agencies throw at them, I also mean gutsy enough to tell the agency to ‘shove it’ when their proposal is rubbish. And let’s face it, there’s plenty of that too.
22 Oct 09
2:38 pm
@OtherAndrew
Gutsy clients = better creative
I totally agree. I also think there is way too much link testing going on, that inevitably leads to watered down creative, and not enough instinctive decision making.
Plus I like the ‘pong’ game on your website. ;->
23 Oct 09
1:48 pm
@Rascally,
Seems we don’t disagree on much after all… hardly as amusing to other readers as flaming each other in true mumbrella fashion, though.
Our site is due for an update but there’s a few people – mostly with more important things to do, incidentally – who I think would complain if we dropped Pong from the new site. If you’re into retro games and are based in Syd then you may enjoy our occasional ‘Arcade Thursdays’ featuring everything from Master System to Super NES, to Wii on the boardroom plasma. Yes, typical agency stuff but great fun… helps with the ‘unfettered creativity’ too.