Media watchdog wins legal battle over suppressed Today’s Hit Network nurse prank call report
The High Court has given the green light to media watchdog the Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA) to publish a controversial report into the prank call by two Today’s Hit Network DJs which led to the suicide of a British nurse.
Today’s unanimous ruling could allow the ACMA to take the Southern Cross Austereo station off-air as punishment for broadcasting the December 2012 prank call which saw hosts Mel Greig and Michael ‘MC’ Christian, who were impersonating Prince Charles and The Queen, put through to the ward where the then pregnant Duchess of Cambridge was being treated for acute morning sickness.
Jacintha Saldanha, the nurse who put the call through to the ward, took her own life days later.
Today’s decision comes six months after the ACMA was given leave to appeal a Federal Court decision that the media authority had overstepped its powers acting as “accuser and fact finder” in creating the report, which is believed to state the station breached the NSW Surveillance Devices Act by airing the secretly recorded call without seeking permission from the nurse or hospital.
That offence would mean the station breached its radio broadcast licence conditions, opening it up to a number of potential punishments by the ACMA including the licence being suspended or cancelled, the imposition of enforceable undertakings to force future compliance, or further licence conditions.
Related content:
The court’s decision found that “the Authority does have power to make an administrative determination that a licensee has committed a criminal offence as a preliminary to taking enforcement action under the BSA, notwithstanding that there has been no finding by a court exercising criminal jurisdiction that the offence has been proven.
“This is because, in making such a determination, the Authority is not adjudging and punishing criminal guilt. The Court also held that, in making a determination, the Authority is not exercising judicial power.”
Comment is being sought from both the ACMA and Southern Cross Austereo (SXL).
Legal action in the case has been ongoing since 2013 when 2DayFM’s applied to block the ACMA from investigating the radio prank and releasing its preliminary report into the court case.
The court ruled that the ACMA would be awarded costs in the case.
Nic Christensen
Related coverage:
So the police have concluded that the incident didn’t breach the act but if ACMA believe otherwise then they have the power to impose penalties? Im sorry, that is just madness!
User ID not verified.
Why don’t the ACMA have the sense to leave this alone?! Hosts Mel Greig & Michael Christian have suffered enough without having to feel responsible for further ramifications. (Even though I will never believe that Jacintha Saldanha choose to end her life based on this event). I wish Mel & Michael every success in the future & hope this event can be put behind them.
User ID not verified.
Nothing of any great significance will come of this though. It will be the equivalent of being flogged with a wet lettuce leaf. A slap over the wrist and a wagging figure with a voice saying “don’t do it again”.
User ID not verified.
Hayley – let me get this straight…… you want to live in a society where all private telephone conversations between innocent parties can be recorded and broadcast to the world without the consent of the parties? just so a radio station can make a couple more bucks?
think about the private conversations you might have had with your family, your doctor, your accountant, your local politician, you boss, your colleagues…..
sou
User ID not verified.
Thank goodness. Shut down 2DayFM.
User ID not verified.
The State police have no jurisdiction outside of NSW and the call occurred in the UK.
User ID not verified.
Legalese – No, that was not my point at all.
I am concerned for the well being of Mel Greig & Michael Christian.
User ID not verified.
Listien; Media Report, Radio National.
User ID not verified.