Choppergate: Nine admits to second faked helicopter live cross
Nine News has promised a full investigation after admitting that it faked another live cross to the network’s chopper while reporting on the search for Daniel Morcombe.
As Mumbrella revealed yesterday, a live cross to the Nine News helicopter purported to show the chopper “near Beerwah”.
In truth it was on the ground at the Nine helipad, with its lights switched off. A rival network captured footage of it and passed it on to Mumbrella. Nine owned up, blaming bad weather leading to a return to base.
It today emerged that a second live cross to Melissa Mallet, the day before, had also been faked after Airservices Australia flight tracker data showed that the helicopter was again nowhere near Beerwah at the time of the cross, despite a caption saying otherwise. The chopper orbited Nine’s headquarters at Mt Coot-tha for about ten minutes prior to the cross, then hovered at just under 3000 ft above nearby Chapel Hill before almost immediately landing again.
Nine Brisbane’s news director Lee Anderson this afternoon issued this message to staff:
“Over the weekend we put to air two live crosses which purported to be from near Beerwah. This was not the case. That we mislead our viewers is totally unacceptable. This afternoon we issued the following public statement:
“During Saturday and Sunday night’s Brisbane bulletin we crossed live to a reporter in our helicopter updating the Daniel Morcombe case.
“On both occasions we said the helicopter was near Beerwah. This was not the case. The fact that the location was misreported is totally unacceptable. We have launched a thorough investigation into all the facts surrounding these reports. Independent of the outcome of that investigation and the action which flows from it , Nine News affirms its unequivocal commitment to complete accuracy in News reporting and to maintaining the trust of our viewers. Nothing less will be tolerated.
“We are determined that such an incident never happen again. To make sure of this we are taking a detailed look at how it occurred.
“Please always, always, always, take extreme care on all matters of accuracy and raise any concerns, however minor you think they might be.”
In both cases the news reader was Eva Milic. The reporter for the faked cross reported yesterday was Cameron Price. The reporter on the fake cross revealed today was Melissa Mallet.
I’m done with all this stuff. It just happens way too much.
The media, in general, needs to forget the race to the bottom. Someone, anyone, needs to take the first step and decide that quality and accuracy are more important than speed and sensationalism.
All it does, in the long run, is undermine any credibility the media has left with the broader public.
User ID not verified.
6 Weeks after the floating restaurant was smashed under the bridge. Channel 7 showed a morning traffic report from their helicopter. The restaurant was still there. I think all the aussie channels need an audit for honesty. They have all forgotten what journalism is about. Today tonight, a current affair. Rediculous rubbish.
User ID not verified.
Nine really is dumbing down and a shadow of its former self. 12 year old reporters (cheap), low rent programming and accountants rather than creatives running a network can really trash a once revered brand. I am amazed they still have a chopper and don’t just rely on locals with phone cameras to get their footage. Thank god i can now download Top Gear a day after it is shown in the UK and i don’t have to watch this network anymore! (Maybe people like me are affecting their revenue stream:)
User ID not verified.
Watch ABC news.. You won’t get any bullshit from them.
User ID not verified.
nine you’ve done it again, first seven takes over now this what has become of our former number one?
User ID not verified.
Who cares where a helicopter is.. its reporting the facts about a missing child. thats the real message here.. Who cars where a helicopter is.. how about wheres daniel ?
lets not forget what is the important story here..
User ID not verified.
Deception is unacceptable, mistakes are forgivable, but I don’t understand why they thought it was necessary?
How was the “reporting” of a dark and closed search site near Beerwah any better because it was supposedly from a helicopter nearby. Just like @loftea reporting from outside the Morcombe’s house during the 6pm news, the location did not improve the content or delivery of the news.
None of these reports were more informative, helpful, credible or newsworthy because of the location of the reporter – truthful or not.
Someone made a decision “I know, let’s get Cameron in the chopper near Beerwah where it’s dark and the search has stopped for the night, that’ll be good”. Who was that, and what was their rationale?
User ID not verified.
This episode is a symptom of a corrosive new culture at Nine which has been imported from the UK by the current network boss of news. Quality of content doesn’t matter, it’s all about the showbiz. It’s not confined to Brisbane but applies across the network. This culture no longer has any appreciation for quality writing and authoritative reporting. Some long termers remain in senior positions at Nine who know the difference between the current crap and past quality. Sadly their views have been suppressed. Perhaps this incident will be a catalyst to restore some appreciation of journalistic excellence in a news service that is now a shadow of its former self.
User ID not verified.
If they can mis-report where the helicopter is, who is to say they wouldn’t go as far as mis-report important information such as “where’s Daniel” as well.
User ID not verified.
I was hoping to see something that would looked obviously faked. You know – bad bluescreen or the camera man shaking the camera to simulate turbulence. This is just too well done. Please Channel 9, please don’t forget the comedy next time…
User ID not verified.
I care Sondra, just as I care enough to include capital letters and apostrophes when I write. The issue here is not what was reported but the deception on the viewers on how it was reported. It’s a pretty simple concept. It’s called honesty.
User ID not verified.
Yes the dumbing down of the media is the fault of Chanel 9 et al.
Wake up.
It’s all you media buyers who are dumbing down the media and you have the audacity to complain about it?
User ID not verified.
I think your commentators need to draw a clear distinction between the purely commercial channels’ TV news and that provided by the ABC and SBS.
As a general rule anyone who gets their “news” from a commercial TV station is an idiot anyway.
If you want actual news and credible journalism on your TV then stick with the ABC and SBS. The commercial networks are a joke.
As for Seven claiming some sort of high ground. I have 4 words. The Chase for Skase.
User ID not verified.
News !?!? Did anyone else think the Nine News special bulletin from the “streets of Darlinghurst” promoted during Underbelly was better suited to at best ACA and at worst a late night doco ??? certainly not one of the nations most widely watched “news” bulletins.
User ID not verified.
Nine’s contempt for its audience’s intelligence is on display on most occasions when it does one of its pathetic live crosses during the news. Why does a reporter have to stand in the wind at the Gap, having her head blown off, to tell the audience about what happened in court that day?
Nine (and the others) are all driving their audiences to international news sources freely available on the internet.
And as to TV’s coverage of political issues…. If it’s a stunt it leads.
User ID not verified.
How is this imported from the UK? I’ve never seen any such crap over there – I’m prepared to be corrected. Oh yeah, listening to other people’s answerphone messages – but directly misleading the audience on TV?
I’ve a good friend who got offered jobs here, and she laughed at the quality of the news reporting, so she stayed at the Beeb. Sky news, Channel4 and ITV all have very credible news coverage, so it’s not commercial vs government.
User ID not verified.
Imported from UK? Did you mean US?
Channel 9 is utter bilge compared to even the most parochial European news station.
User ID not verified.
The fact that the report was live from the chopper was correct. Not all bad.
User ID not verified.
There are only two news broadcasts on Australian television with credibility; ABC’s and SBS’s.
Anyone with half a brain simply cannot take any of 7, 9 or 10’s news seriously(.) (Ok, perhaps George Negus on 10 can be, however that’s it for the 3 mediocre false news networks.)
Sensationalist crap, drivel, b0llocks is what they churn out. So, so Americanised (middle Americanised…) Glam over brains and agenda over credible reporting.
It is so sad. There are so many smart Aussies. We are a well travelled, worldly bunch who love to be informed.
The state of 7, 9 and 10’s broadcasts are beyond a joke. They are laughable, toxic, awful pieces of rubbish.
That’s my ten cents as I watch the SBS deliver yet another exquisite piece of news.
User ID not verified.
Its all about the exclusive and ratings
User ID not verified.