South Solitary: no film is an island
Director Shirley Barrett didn’t get to shoot South Solitary on her dream island, but she found that Plan B is sometimes better. Miguel Gonzalez writes.
Eight years ago Barrett stayed at the first cast concrete lighthouse in Australia, Green Cape, in southern NSW – it now provides accommodation for visitors. She was there doing research for a film she had written, about whaling in the early 1900s. Eventually Barrett came to the conclusion that it was unlikely that the project would ever be made, due to its cost and the VFX it required. Barrett then started reading copies of the lighthouse log book, which described local shipwrecks and how homing pigeons were so well fed and lovingly tended to that, when they were required to fly home, they simply refused to do it. Barrett had found a new idea for a film.
“A small group of people who have to live together in an isolated environment is interesting dramatically from a writer’s perspective, and I thought it would be fairly affordable to make,” said Barrett, who started researching life on Tasmanian ighthouses such as Maatsuyker, Tasman and Deal Islands. She was particularly interested in the time before radio communications, when staff lived in very isolated conditions.
Barret conceived South Solitary as the story of an unmarried 35-year old woman, Meredith (Miranda Otto), who arrives at a remote lighthouse island to assist her strict uncle (Barry Otto), the recentlly-appointed keeper planning on bringing some discipline to the operation. An error of judgement leaves Meredith with a withdrawn assistant (Marton Csokas) as her only companion.
Barrett admits she was embarrassed about “how pedestrian” her first draft was, because the characters were not “right”, particularly the protagonist. When she finally gave Meredith her fighting spirit and had a script she was happy with, Barrett took it to producer Marian Macgowan.
“We started looking at locations the minute we acquired the option in late 2005. Before we could cast or budget we had to know where and how we were going to shoot it,” explained Macgowan. “Shirley was very keen to shoot it on the islands that she’d written about, at Maatsuyker, but I could tell already that there would be logistical problems.”
YOU CAN’T ALWAYS GET WHAT YOU WANT
The film was originally budgeted at $19m, which would allow them to shoot at Maatsuyker Island, a location only accessible by helicopter that would require cast and crew to be accommodated on a ship that would sit off the coast. The shoot would also be longer due to the poor weather conditions. At that stage, South Solitary was structured as a co-production.
“That higher budget was cast-dependent, and getting cast attached to films is extremely difficult. We had high profile actors [Maggie Gyllenhaal and Paul Bettany], and it’s not that they were better [than the final cast]; it would have simply been a different interpretation, a different film,” explained Macgowan. “In my time I’ve learned that, in a sense, it always works out for the best, or what you think will be impossible to deal with always has a solution. There’s always an outcome; all you can do is make the best decisions at the time with the resources you have available.”
When Macgowan found they would not be able to raise $19m, she reduced the budget to $10m, but further adjustments were required.
“We restructured the financing in the middle of 2009, and we needed to cut $3-4m out of the budget. The cash budget was around $6.5m, but the actual budget was a bit higher,” she explained. The project was funded by Screen Australia, Film Victoria, Screen NSW, Omnilab Media, an advance from distributor Icon Film for Australasia, and private investment.
With a much more modest budget, Barrett had to make concessions and shoot on the mainland, not far from Portland, Victoria.
“I was pretty broken-hearted about that at first, but when I got to Cape Nelson and saw what it offered us, it became really exciting because it was down to our craft to get it to feel like an island,” admitted Barrett.
Barrett had lost her dream location, but the new one provided something she did not expect: an original haulage mechanism that was used to ship supplies up the cliff. It was intact and very close to the lighthouse.
“It was a gift from the gods. I can’t tell you how fortunate we were,” said Barrett.
The fact that it was a period film was not a crippling cost, because the production didn’t have to dress up streets or lots of extras due to the story’s isolated setting.
“There are no cars in our world; it’s a fairly straightforward process. The cottages were built in the 1800s, and they are the same now they were then,” said Macgowan.
The film was shot entirely on location, combining the Cape Nelson lighthouse cottage with the interior of the Cape Otway lighthouse.
“The only elements we built were the pigeon house and the outhouse, everything else was there. We just had to create the broken-down world around us,” explained Barrett.
According to the director, production designer Paul Heath and costume designer Edie Kurzer were able to create a low cost look which was authentic and rich in domestic detail.
“My main fear with the visuals was that it would start looking like a glossy 1920s pastiche, which I certainly didn’t want. I wanted it to feel real. I didn’t want everyone to have the latest couture; I wanted it to feel like Meredith sewed her own clothes.
“It was about conveying how difficult it was to live there and the interior of the cottages had to be like the most austere kind of rental locations, with only a kitchen table and a few other things. The challenge I love in period films, especially this one, is researching the details of domestic life and the lighthouse operation. I found that fascinating and luckily so did my team,” explained Barrett.
Barrett and DOP Anna Howard looked at the possibility of using the Red One camera, but ultimately felt that film possessed a “subtle quality” that lent itself to a story that’s set in another time.
“We shot on Super 16 and it’s been blown up to 35mm. It was the right decision, and it also gave us the chance to use small cameras, which was really helpful, being in such confined spaces.
“The film acquired its look without us deliberately going for it. Anna and I didn’t want it to look like it had been treated to get that old film feel, but because we shot on Super 16, we had to go through a process of reducing the grain before we blew it up to 35mm. That process in itself softened the tones a little more. It evolved on its own to look like that,” said Barrett.
There is a climatic violent storm in South Solitary; a combination of practical and CGI effects. That part of the shoot was frustrating for Barrett, not only due to the unseasonably good weather, but also because the area surrounding the lighthouse was so barren that there were no elements – such as trees – to visually show the strength of the wind.
“We didn’t have a big budget and we had to be sparing in our use of CGI. Most of the storm is conveyed with sound, and I believe the combination of real effects, CGI and sound has been really effective,” said Barrett.
The Lab’s VFX supervisor Soren Jensen led the team that created the CG elements of the storm, including debris and the hail that hits the lighthouse window, in addition to rough seas, a steam ship and antique lighthouse lamps. The Lab was also in charge of the grading, done by Al Hansen with help from Vincent Taylor.
AN EXPERIENCED AUDIENCE
South Solitary opened this year’s Sydney Film Festival, an honour that was double-edged for Barrett.
“It’s not the paciest film in the world; it takes its time to unfold and that might be hard on an audience which has already sat down through a few speeches. I felt very honoured, but in some ways it was a tough opening,” admitted the director.
Macgowan says the film’s core audience is women over 35, “a demographic that responds very well to our cast.” When asked about its audience, Barrett hesitated for a moment.
“I always feel a little disappointed when a love story, which is all about longing and a slow burn is resolved too neatly and too completely. I wanted to torture the audience a little, but still give them a little hope. It’s a film that’s satisfying to a female audience, but there are a lot of men that responded well to it too. It is also a film that a slightly older audience would respond to, because you must have a few years on you and a few disappointments in life to get the full measure of the feeling of this film,” argued Barrett.
The film’s sales agent is E1 Entertainment, but Macgowan declined to comment on international sales. It will be released in Australia on July 29.
I thoroughly enjoyed this movie. Absolutely marvellous. Have recommended to friends. Why dont we get more publicity about great Australian movies such as this, instead of all the imported rubbish doing the rounds. So happy to see our actors plauing the roles instead of overseas actors. The Otto’s and Marton Csokas were made for their roles.
User ID not verified.
This is the first Australian film I have seen in quite some time that deserved to be made; it has a great story to tell. Two very damaged characters well portrayed by Csokas and Miranda Otto; in fact all the characters in this story are flawed. Beautiful piece of work
User ID not verified.
This filmwas a surprise, in a good way. I went because I have been out to the real South Solitary Island off Coffs Harbour, however the story and script including lots of authentic almost blokey detail was satisfying. The music was marvellous and doesn’t get mentioned much elsewhere. The sounds were particularly evocative and a good match to the real thing! Four stars.
User ID not verified.
A beautiful depiction of a world where there is only just enough to sustain life and spirit that forces the characters to dig deep and find what it real for them. A delicate period piece, very well cast. Can’t help thinking we have so much we dont really need in our modern cluttered lives.
User ID not verified.
Great movie, great acting! Proud to be an Aussie. Having served from 1959-1964
on Tasmanian Lights: Maatsuyker Island, Tasman Island & Eddystone Point this movie transported me to those Islands & wonderful solitary life.
Wonderful movie I never wanted it to end. Hopefully wil try to see it again.
What great talent we have!
Armand Schepis
User ID not verified.
I saw South Solitary this week and was so impressed, as other Australian films do not impress me this one has class .I lived the whole film —- Congratulations
User ID not verified.
Brilliant movie filmed on a great location and it felt like I believe the 20/30’s were.
Csokas was superb. A great Australian movie. Thankyou.
User ID not verified.
I saw South Solitary last night and I can’t get it out of my mind. I love that sort of movie that stays with you for days. The last movie that did this for me was Disgrace which has an Australian connection too. Everyone of the characters in this movie seemed like very real people. What wonderful actors we have in this country. This movie is not for everyone but I am in the demographic that it was made for and, indeed, I loved it.
User ID not verified.
Well…I’m a (just turned) 45-year-old Perth bloke and I loved this film!. Saw it yesterday afternoon and I’m now sitting here in the following afternoon and still haunted by its windswept rythmns. The tortured aftermath of World War One is part of that…almost the unseen character on the screen. I must admit too that I love lighthouses and the isolation they necessarily bring to human lives and emotions…along with their almost naval/military culture……Congratulations Shirley Barrett you’ve crafted a both beautiful and gutsy piece of Aussie cinema and cast it beautifully. Miranda Otto is quite wonderful…Her character flawed yet never really losing my sympathy……And little Nettie…has there been a more un-nerving child performance in a long time?…….Loved the ending too .. allowed you to imagine what might be….And THAT felt GOOD!………Thankyou to all involved for another wonderful slice of home grown cinema.
User ID not verified.
Saw the film last night. Very much enjoyed it. The sort of film that stays with you. Was interested to view the website & pick up bits I had missed from the film. Also to read the background of earlier lighthouses & see the horrendous haulage at Tasman Island! Good combination of historic element & complex characters thrown together.
User ID not verified.
Wow!!!! what an experience!!on a windswept winter afternoon in Mornington Victoria! My husband and I squeezed into a packed small cinema, we couldn’t even sit together, now that’s real staying power. I had enjoyed Loves Serenade many years ago in the Riverina. So I was really curious about this movie, Otto and Csokas steal the scenes with a slow smolder. Look this film really transported us and the whole audience we were a part of OOOWing and ARHINg, back into time when life was harsher physically and emotionally. Delighted visually, I would love to see it again on a cold windy afternoon, to set the mood, we just didn’t want it to end, great films always leave an impression look forward to the next one.
User ID not verified.
I SO loved this movie. Absolutely exquisite. Brilliant cast, that precocious child just took the cake. What a little gem she is. Contrary to Margaret’s opinion I loved Meredith right to the end and still had sympathy for her despite her not very good decisions. (She reminded me of myself, maybe that’s why) Csokas as the damaged Fleet is sublime. The ending left us with hope and what more can one want. Excellent movie, can’t wait to watch it again.
User ID not verified.
Miranda Otto and Marton Csokas were brilliant together. Great cast all round. The film gave you some insight what life must have been like in the early days before communication. Congratulations on a great Australian film. We need more like this. Well done.
Lorraine D’Orsogna
Margaret River
Western Australia
User ID not verified.
I loved this movie. The idea of so much isolation,and unlikly love.
I was left wanting her to stay.
Living in Coffs Harbour I thought the movie was made on South Solitary Island in our own back yard,I was dissapointed to find that was not the case. Anyway I still enjoyed the movie
User ID not verified.
I only found this little film by an amazing co-incidence and because my Great Grandfather was a REAL head keeper, on the REAL South Solitary in the early 1900’s….well I had to be interested didn’t I? It was obviously a slight disappointment that it wasn’t filmed on the real island ( just off Coffs Harbour NSW, where everything is intact )..However, Barret and Co. have done an outstanding job grafting footage from Cape Nelson, Cape Otway and sparing amounts of CGI to create a very believable island setting…one that closely resembles the skyline silhouette of the real one….a not so small detail that those of us who know the history, really appreciated. I agree with everyone else’s comments that both Barry and especially Miranda Otto were fantastic in their roles. ALL the supporting actors were very well cast and most credible. For me though, Marton Csokas wholly OWNED his damaged WW1, Welshman …..an absolute stand-out characterization! I felt the cinematography was superb, especially considering the small format that they used ( 16mm ). The music did not dominate and yet it disappeared seamlessly into the greater whole…so it very much did its job. “She moved through the fair” being one of my all-time favourite Irish Ballads, and well chosen for the mysticism within it’s own lyrics. Well done all round !! A film that nourished me both as a movie-o-holic as well as a person with deep family connection to Light-houses.
User ID not verified.
I must give credit to ABC iview for bringing this movie forward as I catch up on the Australian classics during lockdown. I found the pace and direction hauntingly beautiful. Perfectly cast and meticulously shot, it is in my top ten Australian films. Thank you!
User ID not verified.