Lowe creative chief counters Hegarty’s view on scam: We learn from testing like an F1 team
The global creative head at ad agency Lowe has countered the views of John Hegarty, who said yesterday that the Cannes Lions advertising festival was “losing focus” on genuine advertising that builds brands.
Jose Miguel Sokoloff, Lowe’s global chief creative officer, said that he “disagreed” with the BBH founder and described scam – work created to win awards – as like a Formula One racing team.
“I have to disagree with John. I agree that there is a lot of work created just for awards, but think of it like a Formula 1 operation. Honda has a F1 programme just to win races. But also what they learn from testing becomes part of the car’s engine,” he said.
“Brand building advertising has radically changed. It’s not all about television anymore or creating huge ads. It’s about the many small ways that brands affect our lives and become larger.”
“We have to accept there’s a different landscape now, rather than saying that all work is scam. A lot of the work is real, but it’s small scale work,” he said.
Yesterday, Hegarty described scam as an “abberation” and like “drugs in sport.”
“It is a delusional practice, and the problem is we’ve created a beast called awards and it’s taken over,” he said.
“What Cannes should be all about is how creativity aids branding and builds business. But are we really seeing the ideas that are creating effective work? I’m not sure that we are,” he said.
Sokoloff also responded to Hegarty’s views on technology. Hegarty said yesterday that the industry has become “so obsessed” with technology that it was becoming distracted from the real purpose of advertising – “delivering messages that moves people.”
Sokoloff said that adland’s preoccupation with new technology is nothing new.
“We went through an era of overproduced, bad ideas in TV with CGI [computer generated imagery]. In the beginning, there was too much of it,” he said.
Sokoloff added: “We get enamoured with new technology, we love it. But we need to learn how to use it first. Sometimes we use technology for technology’s sake.”
Robin Hicks in Cannes
Honda has no F1 programme to win races, in 2014.
User ID not verified.
Can we please stop the car analogies for trying to justify award scams. Neither F1 teams or prototypes for car shows (which has been used in a previous thread) has any similarities to putting forward scams for awards.
User ID not verified.
Scam ads never break new ground, they’re typically print executions tailored at the somewhat narrow taste of award juries – Saatchi’s Panasonic “campaign” being the perfect example
User ID not verified.
Jose misses the point. Formula1 vehicles don’t race against production vehicles. Jose does neither himself or Lowes credit.
User ID not verified.