When the CEO’s fist smashed into the table… I finally learned something.
In this guest post, Ashton Bishop calls for agencies to stop pretending they understand their client’s business
You can’t work in advertising without pitching. And you haven’t worked in advertising until you’ve brutally lost one.
My brutal humiliation happened five years ago when a major media client interrupted us mid-sentence.
It was the classic agency line our MD was parading: “See the thing is that we know your business and…”
Bang! Their CEO’s fist hits the table. “No you don’t know our fucking business!”
The rest of the pitch was a disaster and it was only later, while licking our wounds, that I realised there was lemonade in the lemon the CEO threw across the table.
See in my previous 10 years or so in agencyland, at every place I’d worked across Australia and the UK the agency line had always been, ‘our difference is we really understand our client’s business’. And it became the charade we all got trained in and acted out each day.
It’s a lie.
You see the truth is, we don’t know their business. We certainly knew a fair bit about advertising, took an interest in their business, and even tracked their sales. That’s not the same as working in the business, across sales, operations, HR, finance and sitting in on board meetings. So why pretend?
Because we were pretending we knew, we were often not asking the dumb questions for fear of looking dumb. We also had our advertising filter on, which became a campaign solution filter. Campaigns became the advertiser’s god. We looked for a big idea and one neat solution to all their problems.
Now, we all know if the answer’s complex, then the question’s probably not right. But what we were missing was that there might be more than one question.
So my fist slam/ fist pump moment was this: Give up the ‘we know your business’ arrogance and give up the worship at the advertising/campaign altar. Then start thinking in terms of marketing fundamentals. How do customers find out about you? How are you addressing their concerns? What’s happening around the sale? How are you delivering the product/service? What’s the follow-up?
Some brands that really get this way of thinking are nakedwines.com.au, Hot Milk lingerie and The Clean Plumber. You don’t need to see a campaign to be talking about them.
So how can you action this way of thinking? Avoid taking a brief in isolation, but collaborate with clients on the above questions and, only once the fundamentals are strong, do you then lay the campaign over the top.
It’s as simple as letting your clients tell you about their business and ask the dumb questions. In a place of honesty about what you know and, more importantly, don’t, you get the space to create strategies and ideas that can help clients get better results, sooner and for less. It’s just not done enough.
Ashton Bishop is the head of strategy at Step Change Marketing
Is that THE puffy shirt?
User ID not verified.
Surely this is just Wil Wheatons “Don’t be a dick”?
User ID not verified.
agree with everything in this article, except those 3 companies he mentioned who have apparently nailed their marketing approach.. never heard of any of them.
User ID not verified.
It seems like clients don’t know their business either. Often they haven’t asked themselves the fundamentals.
User ID not verified.
it’s a good point – I used to work in government and the agencies that would turn up there always pulled the line “we know how government works”. If only they did!!
User ID not verified.
Its not about knowing our clients business, its about understanding it – which is a very different thing. And we do need to understand it in order to work with them. If you don’t, how can you possibly advise them on media strategy / buying / planning / etc?
User ID not verified.
I agree Ash. The sentiment is spot on. Be honest from the start. The arrogance in the “we know your business” statement is astounding.
User ID not verified.
Well said Ash. The best work comes from great partnerships, with agency & client respecting each other’s expertise. Your article reminded me of the Avis Rent A Car Advertising Philosophy, crafted by Avis CEO Robert Townsend and DDB’s Bill Bernbach in 1962. The first point of the six-point philosophy reads:
“1. Avis will never know as much about advertising as DDB and DDB will never know as much about the rent a car business as Avis”
User ID not verified.
Great article. There’s a major agency working with our business that could learn a thing or two from this article. Despite multiple interactions over a number of years, they still don’t get what the business is about. The advertising guys love it, but the attitude from others who are more knowledgable of the business is “who are these guys and why are they telling me about my own company?”.
User ID not verified.
Fabulous perspective, and certainly one that is making the difference for your company.
User ID not verified.
I think that to tell a client that you understand “their business” is presumptive. However, if you do not understand “the business” that the client is in now, and how that business could develop, then what are you offering them?
User ID not verified.
Point well made, and it certainly applies to PR. I once told a prospective client’s people that I knew nothing about their industry sector, but I did know about PR, and it seemed that PR expertise was what they wanted. Still working with those people 10 years later and considered a specialist in that industry. Oh, and I still don’t know their industry as well as they do.
User ID not verified.
The main thing agencies understand is the need to justify their existence. Media and Advertising isn’t a black art. It’s simply a relationship between buyers (clients) and suppliers (media owners), like any other business… only with far too many people in the middle to muddy the waters. Yes, I’m sure the 22 year old buyer who buys spots for 4 different clients based on who can get grand final or ANTM tickets “understands your business”.
User ID not verified.
Wot, you mean like be honest and humble and that.
Do some research so you like knows what you do and want you dont know. And then talk with the client (owner or responsible party) who lives and breathes the business) with respect for his knowledge and a sensible request for him to inform you further on all that stuff what you dont know.
So we shouldnt just rock in looking pretty and dazzle him with our general omniscience?? I thought the ad industry worked because we are all groovy special people, with the world just waiting for our pearls of wisdom.
I jest of course …..But seriously good pointer Ashton.
User ID not verified.
One bad meeting with Kerry Packer could have told you all that and you wouldn’t have had to tell such a long story.
User ID not verified.
Well said Ash, I agree very much. Not being in the same business as your client does not mean that you shouldn’t understand their business after time and a deeply involved relationship. But being too premature in making such a big statement deserves the slap down.
User ID not verified.
A great article that doesn’t surprise me. My experience as a client of Step Change Marketing is that they do exactly that. They are very smart at “co-creating” and building on the knowledge that already exists in the business. A great read Ash!
User ID not verified.
Thanks for sharing Ash.
Couldn’t agree more @Joe Talcott
User ID not verified.
Jason @ 3:15pm – you are spot on!
“If I buy X amount of spots with Channel Y, will they take me out for lunch next week?”
User ID not verified.
Danny & Jason, I think you’re right that SOME people in media behave like this, but they’re the people who do this job for the perks and ultimately aren’t passionate enough to do a good job, they can’t handle the work and end up leaving (or at least, end up getting a reputation for being rubbish at their job).
Media owners and many agencies are smart enough to catch people out who behave in this way and there are serious consequences.
Your comments may be based on personal experience, but in the 10+ years that I’ve been working in agencies the lunches, tickets, etc are not based on an agreement to buy “x in return for y” – they are an extra, unexpected perk (which some agencies need to declare) that also genuinely helps to build relationships with media owners and is part of our job. Clients are often made aware of or invited to lunches to say thank you for business.
I have experienced more occasions where the shoe is on the other foot and media owners say “if you buy x, we will give you y” – in every instance I’m aware of this type of unethical behaviour is shut down immediately.
I’m not naive and understand that some people take the piss, but they’re a minority, not the norm.
User ID not verified.