The Australian TV industry needs to ditch the Logies ASAP
The Logies make TV look stale, old and terminal, and no marketer wants to be a part of it, argue's CHE Proximity's chief media officer Ben Shepherd. The industry needs to walk away now, before the fun and games of this year's roasting turn more problematic.
There were two large events last week. One was the Logie Awards and the other was the Adobe Symposium. Let’s first look at the Logies. The Logies on Sunday were not the best three-hour advertisement for the TV industry.
The winner of the Gold used 10 minutes to deliver a cutting assessment of the current state of the industry – admitting openly he’d gamed the awards in an obvious fashion and won the award.
He admitted he wasn’t the most popular person on TV.
He stated the industry was dying.
He acknowledged that ad-free subscription channels like Stan and Netflix were where viewers attention was heading.
The largest free-to-air networks were nowhere to be found in the winners list, and the ABC – which has been attacked more than ever over the past 12 months – was the biggest winner.
It was bizarre, and to the viewer looked more like a wake than a celebration. It was a roast to the industry where a lot of the participants didn’t realise they were being roasted.
The ratings were another red flag to TV. It rated 885,000 metro viewers across the five capital cities. 43.1% of the viewers were over 55. Only 23% were under 35. What does that say about our TV stars and the audiences who follow them? It says they’re not young, that’s for sure.
TV cannot have its night of nights look like this if it wants to present as modern, progressive and relevant to all audiences. The Logies make TV look stale, old and terminal.
Three days earlier, Adobe hired out the ICC and put on the Adobe Symposium. Every marketer with any influence was there. As were the teams. And their agencies. Every consultancy was there. Every technology company was there. Everyone was there.
Adobe put on an event that was expensive. It celebrated its clients. Marketers want to be on that stage. It has become the event and it positions Adobe in the centre of the modern marketing ecosystem.
The audience was relevant and powerful. The industry is thriving. And you know what? Most of them paid to be there.
Can TV compete with it? It’s yet to be seen, but the technology platforms are their main competition.
And it’s not going to beat them if it thinks the Logies are an industry endorsement worth broadcasting anymore. No marketer wants to go to the Logies, but they all want to go to Adobe Symposium.
Ben Shepherd is the chief media officer at CHE Proximity. This piece was originally published on LinkedIn, and has been republished here with permission.
Spot on with this article….but where will the white male dinosaurs then graze?
User ID not verified.
In another life I would have attended 30 Logies minimum 70s 80s and 90s and into the 2000s.
I worked for 2 commercial networks thru that time and Logies was a true celebration of a fabulous era in television. The best local dramas where produced, comedy was brilliant with mother and son, fast forward, kingswood country, comedy company with hilarious sketches you get the drift. They where the back bone of tv along with 60 minutes and news and current affairs offerings.
Now with the greatest respect to the gold Logie nominees they where not a candle to actors/ actress of days gone by.
People did buy tv week, viewers did have an opinion both thru diaries and people meter measurement and expressed that by a tick or a click.
What I saw Sunday night was a joke and ratings showed that 850k???? Days I dwell on 2m bank on it. Someone needs to seriously consider if the current rubbish is worth the $ they cost. Also the egos are matched by salaries that will cripple the industry.
User ID not verified.
Please respond Kim Portrate, Michael Stevenson, Kurt Burnette and Rod Prosser. So many flaws in this…
User ID not verified.
I couldn’t agree more, well said.
User ID not verified.
Perhaps if the main networks did more than just rehash cheesy reality formats, things might be different.
Look at what is winning, quality, programs given time to find a niche, programs built with a real audience, not just ‘as mass as possible’. If anything, this should be a wake up call to 7, 9 and 10, that even with constant budget attacks, the ABC is producing the best TV in the country.
User ID not verified.
Could u pick a softer target.
User ID not verified.
Also see: https://www.aacta.org/aacta-awards/
User ID not verified.
I don’t get the relevance. It’s odd you say everyone was there – yet the surrounding streets of the ICC was not busier than normal.
BTW, what channel was the Adobe Symposium on? I’m guessing it was pay per view!
User ID not verified.
This article is an obvious trojan horse, and Mumbrella fell for it. This subtle paragraph gave it away . . .
“Three days earlier, Adobe hired out the ICC and put on the Adobe Symposium. Every marketer with any influence was there. As were the teams. And their agencies. Every consultancy was there. Every technology company was there. Everyone was there”
Yeah, right. This is awful, 101 marketing.
CHE Proximity is an Adobe Partner, and love to enter the Adobe Summit awards. Plus, and this is where it gets more worrisome, they appear to be gunning for more from Adobe . . .
https://adobe.cheproximity.com.au/
Note the redirect to /client.
At the very least, this should have been disclosed. At worst, this article found the softest of targets and was completely disingenuous. Not what we would expect from CHE, or Mumbrella.
User ID not verified.
Who the hell would compare the Logies to Adobe Symposium? It’s not a trade event designed to attract business…its not for marketers.
Is the Logies a bit naff, yes. But it’s always been that way – it’s free tv for goodness sake.
As to your point around no major commercial network – Didn’t 10 get like 6?
User ID not verified.
His point about the Logies about being awful is spot on, but to compare it to the Adobe sales event is wrong. Every TV station Upfront gets more C-level executives than Adobe does…
User ID not verified.
Agreed.
User ID not verified.
Some interesting point in this interesting article.
And Ben, just checking in – how long have you been working in the Australian television industry, what is your network experience, how many shows have you worked on, how long have you been covering it as a journalist and what are your credentials for making a raft of claims like this?
Mumbrella, if you are going to get someone to comment on the state of the Logies, please use an informed source and someone who actually knows something about the topic they’re writing about. But well done to Ben to achieve his spin and get a plug in for the Adobe Symposium. Nice touch.
User ID not verified.
Thank you & well said. This looks like an advertorial for the adobe symposium. Shame on you Mumbrella! Also how is that a direct comparison. The Logies is the your average low & middle socio economic Aussie, not just for marketers!!
User ID not verified.
YOU SPEAK THE TRUTH!!!
I am a 31 yo female, (semi)-typical Millennial who values entertainment in all forms (TV, film, music, etc.) and I have never and would NEVER watch the logies. It is such a far cry from what “young people” find appealing or interesting… it’s old, dated, not cool.
I never really resonated with Aussie (free to air) TV or the hosts who star in them anyway, mostly because I never saw enough brown skinned people on there that I could relate to as an Australian… even though we’re one of the culturally diverse countries in the world. Anyway, another can of worms that has been opened and heard many, many times before.
Couldn’t agree with this article more.
User ID not verified.
My thoughts exactly!
User ID not verified.
Mumbreall360 probably got more C Suite speakers and attendees than Adobe Symposium…
User ID not verified.
Failing to disclose that CHE Proximity are an Adobe partner in this article absolutely reeks. This is appalling and way below Mumbrella’s standards. Do better – add a disclaimer and apologise.
User ID not verified.
Mumbrella and Ben are merely highlighting the joke that passes off as industry awards.
I have worked in the industry at the highest levels and watched the award’s night degenerate into nothing more than a fashion parade and pissup.
Tim Worner and Hugh Marks, the heads of the two leading networks, must shoulder the blame for letting this debacle to continue.
My free advice to both you learned men is boycott the night until substantial changes are made to the voting system.
How can you both sit by and accept programs like the Project, which takes the piss out of the news, wins the award for best Current Affairs program. Have you not watched ACA, 60mins, Sunday Night, Australian Story, 730 report?
It’s in your best interests to take a stand and stop the farce that is the Logies.
User ID not verified.
I thought this article was a load of BS. The viewing figures for the Logies were actually up on last year and while I think there is a massive issue with the voting process that doesn’t mean the awards should be ditched. A good marketer would look for solutions rather than throwing away an event that’s been going for 61 years.
And where was the detail on why the Adobe even was better? To my knowledge just about everyone in television wants to go to the logies, so even that claim seems ridiculous. But you know, people are gunna keep bashing tv… it’s low hanging fruit (although still one of the biggest games in town)
User ID not verified.
Oh my! This is all happening right after the Adobe Symposium keynote dwelled on the importance of brand purpose! Well, here’s one value that CHE Proximity should adopt in this networked and inclusive digital landscape: transparency.
User ID not verified.
– Three days earlier, Adobe hired out the ICC and put on the Adobe Symposium.
Sounds like a real laugh riot.
BTW, most of the audience were _paid_ to be there….
User ID not verified.
Hmmm, I bet if you ask 1,000 people which event they’d rather attend: The Logies or The Adobe Symposium, there’d be a lot of empty seats at the latter. In fact I bet if you asked everyone at The Adobe Symposium to stand up if they’d rather be at The Logies, you’d have a lot of bums off seats. It’s a hoot. And this year’s event was the biggest hoot of all. But it also made a great many serious and salient points about disability, diversity, sustainability and press freedom. Best of all, Costa turned up in a suit he bought from Lifeline. Hoping the Logies becomes even more relevant next year with a special category for Op Shop Couture.
User ID not verified.
While I agree that the Logies were shit (and have been for at least a decade) … but comparing it to the Adobe Symposium?!?!
And the article’s selling point … “Every marketer with any influence was there. As were the teams. And their agencies. Every consultancy was there. Every technology company was there.”
I could not think of anything as boring to the public as that.
What audience do you think the Adobe Symposium would get it if it was telecast to the general public? Probably two decimal places to the left … 8.85k.
Just shows how distorted things can be when you live in a bubble.
User ID not verified.
I’m a senior and my daughter is a millennial and we both thought the Logies were crass. It was a bit like watching the Oscars but at a much lower level, award wise and talent.
User ID not verified.
Justine, I find the many comments like yours – “I have never watched the Logies, I’ve never watched the Logies” – the height of hypocrisy.
If you have never watched them, then how are you informed enough to critique them? How is this a valid judgement?
I never watch cricket, therefore I would never criticise coverage of it – as I am not a qualified to do so. How about you watch a few Logies, understand what they stand for and their legacy, and then maybe consider offering a valid view once you have done that? It might be a bit more constructive than more of the “I’ve never watched the Logies” reactions we have had over the past few days.
User ID not verified.
… or at least introduce a series of industry vote categories , so it gains credibility.
User ID not verified.
Say whatever you want about the Logies and you’d probably be right, but at least people have heard of it. Your mum cares about Cannes Lions about as much as she cares about the Australian Dental Industry Awards.
User ID not verified.
I’m a big fan of the Toothies tbh.
User ID not verified.
How hard is it to buy a 100 Tarps a week these days?
User ID not verified.
One could deduce that a bloke who has demanded from pubs in the past to be taken on international junkets (like Cannes) probably [Edited under Mumbrella’s comment moderation policy]
And to disguise this farce of an article as a “Media State Of Play” is an insult to your industry peers. As noted above, there was plenty of interest in the Symposium, but nobody went there for free – they were all paid to do so.
Next time you attempt to build a Trojan Horse, bring more wood.
User ID not verified.
Yeah, but would you prefer to watch the Adobe event instead?
User ID not verified.
“I have worked in the industry at the highest levels and watched the award’s night degenerate into nothing more than a fashion parade and pissup.”
isn’t this true for all industry award shows? In fact, isn’t it the entire point?
User ID not verified.
Was there something on commercial TV we missed?
User ID not verified.
This is a great pickup. Ben usually has a great POV but this one stinks a bit considering the relationship is not disclosed. In his defense it states that he originally posted this on LinkedIn and Mumbrella requested it to republish it here. So really they should have been the ones to dig a bit deeper and uncover the conflict.
User ID not verified.
Good call by anyone who called out CHEP on their appalling efforts at transparency. If this demonstrates their skills at Content Marketing, then buyer beware.
If Mumbrella did indeed ask to republish this from LinkedIn, then clickbait and commentbait spring to mind. If not – why bother giving them a channel and endorsing this “advertorial”.
For those dismissing the value of the older audiences that the Logies attracted – yet again the youth bubble of the industry is neglecting the value of a large and valuable customer segment that is still very valuable to advertisers and brands trying to reach them. Whether they will want to watch after this year’s Gold Logie debacle – who knows?
User ID not verified.
Bluey winning a logie was probably the most worthwhile and deserving logie winner of all time though, so they got one thing right….
User ID not verified.
Clearly you have never watched the actual Logies, or you would have known that half of the Awards are voted by TV industry experts, not the public. And to everyone else here who feels the need to make uninformed comments, this year’s most popular actress was Deborah Mailman, most popular drama was Mystery Road whose cast had many outstanding indigenous actors that were also nominated, respected and revered journalist Kerry O’Brien was inducted into the Hall of Fame, and more women took to the winners podium than men.
And remember, the key demographics that spend the household budget each week, well, I know what they were watching on Sunday night.
User ID not verified.
Justine
You made this comment:
“…because I never saw enough brown skinned people on there that I could relate to as an Australian
This, from Mick below:
“…this year’s most popular actress was Deborah Mailman, most popular drama was Mystery Road whose cast had many outstanding indigenous actors that were also nominated, respected and revered journalist Kerry O’Brien was inducted into the Hall of Fame, and more women took to the winners podium than men.
Might be helpful if you watched next time before shooting from the hip
User ID not verified.
https://www.theage.com.au/entertainment/celebrity/tom-gleeson-was-the-best-thing-to-happen-to-the-logies-in-years-20190703-p523lm.html
User ID not verified.
Good to see some spirited debate on this – in answer to some of the comments made.
1/ my main point was the tv industry deserves a better advertisement for itself and it’s audience engagement than the Logies. Some may disagree but I don’t think it represents the industry and where it’s at – TV deserves better
2/ sure it rated 885k and was marginally up – but nine could have gotten that audience number for less cost and resource.
3/ the comparison to adobe wasn’t as blunt as comparing an awards ceremony and a conference – it was comparing two competitors and their public facing marketing endeavours that week. Software platforms are the greatest competitor that fta has and we need to consider why these platforms are growing at such high rates compared to traditional media.
4/ I am not aware of any CHE Proximity conflicts with Adobe or even the FTA networks but will check. These did not influence any of the article – please remember as an agency we work with all media vendors including the FTA networks closely. If there are associations that need to be disclosed they will be.
5/ re claims of ageist tone – the viewers are who they are, I was pointing it out. All I was saying was FTA represents itself as a channel with a wide demographic consuming it but the Logies didn’t demonstrate it – it played to stereotypes around TV viewers.
Thanks for reading.
User ID not verified.
“TV’s night of nights” is the most cringe over-used phrase in media.
User ID not verified.
RE Your main point above:
It’s the ‘TV WEEK’ Logie Awards – the Most Popular Awards VOTED FOR by loyal TV WEEK magazine readers.
Why is it so hard for everyone from the punters to the media to understand this?
If you don’t even know how the Logies work, why comment?
User ID not verified.
Ill say!
User ID not verified.
Ageist racist and sexist. Well done
User ID not verified.
They will easily find a place to do so, owning as they do, the world.
User ID not verified.