ABC facing calls to relinquish New Year fireworks coverage after renewed criticism
The ABC’s coverage of the New Year fireworks in Sydney has come in for major criticism from hundreds of viewers and media outlets for the second year in succession, and calls to relinquish the rights to a commercial broadcaster.
It was the second year the public broadcaster has shown the event after taking over the rights from commercial rival Channel Nine, with Sydney’s Daily Telegraph today publishing an editorial headlined “ABC’s New Year’s Eve coverage needs a cracker up its clacker”, a reference to a famous headline from News Corp stablemate the NT Times.
In it Claire Harvey wrote: “I’m a devoted ABC viewer and even I found the coverage patronising, amateurish, tedious and intermittently baffling.”
Viewers took to social media to vent their anger at the coverage (click to enlarge)
Hundreds of viewers took to Facebook and Twitter to criticise the coverage, which at one point saw HG Nelson’s head blocking a camera showing the fireworks, labelling it amongst other things “embarrassing” and “awful”.
Among the criticisms were too many mentions of the ABC’s funding cuts, and poor vision of the fireworks at midnight and overly long and uncomfortable interviews with guests.
The show was hosted by Julia Zemiro and actor Toby Truslove, with crosses to Tom Ballard, Lawrence Mooney, Charlie Pickering and Adam Zwar amongst others. At the end of te broadcast Zemiro was heard saying “oh thank God” when she thought her microphone had been turned off.
Yesterday the ABC had promised “unrivalled coverage” of the event with nine cameras, a helicopter and “Australian first” use of drones to capture footage.
This morning the ABC claimed the broadcast was watched by 4m viewers nationally, up from 3.7m last year for the whole broadcast, with 2m tuning into the main channel and ABC News 24 for the fireworks coverage between 11.55pm and 12.22am, giving it a 19.7 per cent audience share.
In a statement on the ratings Justin Holdforth, ABC head of sport and events said: “The Sydney New Year’s Eve fireworks are an iconic and much loved event. I’m delighted that the ABC was again able to deliver a spectacular night of family entertainment to audiences across Australia”
Last year the ABC’s director of television Richard Finlayson defended its coverage from similar criticism of the four hour broadcast.
The ABC has been contacted for comment.
Alex Hayes
Some of the reaction on Twitter (click to enlarge)
i disagree.
i would rather watch some bad jokes than endless plugs for “The Block”
KEEP IT ON THE ABC.
User ID not verified.
It was an embarrassing broadcast and one the ABC should apologies for.
User ID not verified.
The actual ABC full coverage of Sydney’s New Years Fireworks was spectacular and full credit to its producers . The one thing that marred it was the poor quality of the 2 hosts who spoiled it throughout their vocabulary and stupid remarks .Lets hope next New Years eve the powers to be select 2 better hosts to present the show as the ones last night rate 2/10
User ID not verified.
who’s this “Charlie truslove”? Never heard of him. His long-lost brother Toby on the other hand… heard of him. Has Mumbrella had budget cuts over New Year too???
User ID not verified.
Zameiro ruins everything she touches. She is puerile and full of herself.
User ID not verified.
Well, if the Daily Telegraph says so, it must be an unbridled piece of public spirited opinion.
User ID not verified.
I stayed at home due to a drinking problem thinking i could still have a sober fun new
year whilst watching the ABC broadcast of the fire works with my family.unfortunately
it was such a disgrace it made me drink after two and a half years of sobriety.Happy
new year ABC .ps have a good look at yourselves i did.
User ID not verified.
Didn’t watch it so cannot comment however, Lindsay…your observation would be more credible without the spelling errors.
User ID not verified.
keep it on the abc
User ID not verified.
I respectfully disagree with Richard, who I believe was watching a different telecast to the one we saw. It was embarrassing, poor quality TV. Don’t criticise the presenters who were being directed. The producers have lost contact with every age group.
User ID not verified.
I agree with Liana’s comment.
User ID not verified.
and again tonight the leftist comedy geeks of the abc take over the 7.30 timeslot to rub whatever in the average viewers face forcing the traditional 7.30 edinburgh tattoo into a later timeslot. who is in control.
User ID not verified.
The hosts were Julia Zemiro and *Toby* Truslove.
It’s very easy to write an article saying “social media was angry about something”. It’s always angry.
User ID not verified.
Hi Steve and Dan,
Thanks for flagging- changed now.
Steve to your point, it is easy to write ‘social media is angry’ which is why we don’t often do it, but in this case the number of complaints were significant enough to warrant noting.
Cheers,
Alex – editor, Mumbrella
Hey, any New Years Eve coverage that includes Jimmy Giggle and both Hoot and Hootabelle is win in my book.
User ID not verified.
i was in a caravan park in Tasmania , and the dog licking its bum on the porch across the road was more entertaining than the abc coverage of nye . One host kept making jokes about his jacket, and how it wasn’t bought at a store, but handmade by ex abc journalists . Newsflash buddy, firstly it wasn’t funny the first time you said it, second looks like you ate a few of those journalists and have to get clothes specially made anyway
User ID not verified.
The Daily Telegraph has a problem with the ABC’s coverage… well, who didn’t see that coming. I am just surprised The Australian didn’t weigh in on the debate.
I’d prefer the event stay on the ABC rather than hand it over to a commercial network who will only do a mediocre job themselves but with more reality show “celebrities”.
User ID not verified.
I was physically embarrassed by the most amateurish live coverage of an event in recent memory. Give the broadcast rights to a professional outfit.
User ID not verified.
it was shithouse.
User ID not verified.
Unfortunately Jula Zemiro is never funny – her coverage of Eurovision on SBS made that clear. Someone who can be fun, insightful and not patronising or superior – and who knows when to stop talking – is what’s needed.
As for the others, I’d never heard of most of them.
The ABC shouldn’t try to compete with the commercials in terms of being puerile, but rather make use of some of their talented presenters. After all, that’s why we ABC/SBS viewers shun the commercial channels – for intelligent coverage.
User ID not verified.
Fireworks on Television on any channel are always a FIZZER !!!!
User ID not verified.
I was most disappointed about the midnight fireworks, which were pixelated and constantly freezing for seconds at a time on the ABC. I presume that this was footage from the drones.
User ID not verified.
Thank you to all those who commented on my spelling. Decades of hard work have gone into trying to improve it, but the dyslexia persists. It is not really all that important. Unlike the production standards of the ABC which is a topic worthy of public discussion.
User ID not verified.
Worst coverage ever. Total embarrassment. Also had my kids watching and had to change channel a couple of times when people started swearing. Not needed and the beeps were not well placed.
GIVE IT BACK TO NINE!
User ID not verified.
It was embarrassingly rubbish coverage, i could strap a go-pro on my cat for a few hours and come up with better television.
User ID not verified.
I quite liked it and appreciated not having to watch 1000 ads promoting next years MKR or The Block ‘twists’. Filling 4 hours is no mean feat with a climax of fireworks which are really not made for TV anyway. The pub quiz was enjoyable and I assume families would have found fun. If it was on another channel everyone would have complained anyway, it’s what social media is for.
User ID not verified.
Remember nine’s coverage of the Olympics? Eddie McGuire waffling the while time during the ceremony. You also had the constant cutting away from events if Australia wasn’t going to get a medal. It was great the coverage not being full of adverts.
User ID not verified.
I would have thought that most people would know that the ABC doesn’t broadcast events for the people or the average Australian.
It only broadcasts for it’s own self indulgence and it’s self centre inner city watchers
Speak up long and load enough and maybe next years fireworks display will be back to where it belongs with commercial TV thats represents the real Australia and not a minority
User ID not verified.
I found the coverage to be puerile and disjointed. It was particularly jarring when the program went from lame jokes, laughter and costumes to a recap of 2013, filled with plane crashes, war and other human tragedies.
User ID not verified.
@cktopsy
Completely agree, this is why the ABC must be privatised.
User ID not verified.
ABC’s New Year’s Eve program was not as bad as 2013, but that’s not really a compliment. The presenters were embarassing and made me cringe – please tell me that this broadcast was not seen outside Australia. There’s no need to try so hard to come across as a loud mouthed bogan yobbo. Where were the talented ABC presenters ? If that’s the best you can do, please give it back to Channel 9 – at least Richard Wilkins has some style!!
User ID not verified.
People said the ABC could not *possibly* do any worse than last year…..man did they get a surprise. Give it back to Nine or Ten..ANYONE else…PLEASE…
User ID not verified.
The live cross to Perth in broad daylight was silly and a total embarrassment. ABC even played an episode of “Nowhere Boys” just before the Family Fireworks. Very inappropriate for young children. The hosts were unfunny and boring. Give it back to 9 and let Karl Stefanovic and Lisa Wilkinson host the event. Richard Wilkins presents an ARIA countdown on the forecourt of the Opera House.
User ID not verified.
Thank goodness that Sky news on foxtel also had the nye fireworks coverage. After the 9pm fireworks on abc I quickly channel surfed. The other option was to stand outside with a sparkler in each hand and my own lame commentry!!!
User ID not verified.
“I would have thought that most people would know that the ABC doesn’t broadcast events for the people or the average Australian.
It only broadcasts for it’s own self indulgence and it’s self centre inner city watchers
Speak up long and load enough and maybe next years fireworks display will be back to where it belongs with commercial TV thats represents the real Australia and not a minority”.
*slaps forehead* When did Mumbrella start stealing readers from the Daily Tele?
User ID not verified.
yep give it to commercial telly, that way it will got to pay tv and youll not see it unless you are subscribed to murdox or that other mob
User ID not verified.
Most commenters are missing the real point.
Sydney NYE is the same boring format that it has been for the past 18 years, because the City of Sydney hasn’t got the guts or ingenuity to change it. It’s exactly the same as it was back in 1996. Not even a tiny bit different. Groundhog Night!
The Fotis do brilliant fireworks, but that’s them, not the council. And it’s the only part of “the show” that people like. The rest is garbage.
Sydney deserves better, a lot better.
This event should be removed from the hands of a local council with all the small-mindedness that entails, and taken over by the NSW government which has a more global focus and can make it a genuinely global event.
User ID not verified.
Sorry Mike, but I think it is you who is missing the point. It is not the fireworks (or events associated with it) that have been commented on here, but the second-rate ABC New Year’s Eve broadcast. The ABC does many things extremely well, especially news and current affairs. May be the problem the ABC has with covering the Sydney fireworks is nobody outside of the city really cares what is going on in Sydney on New Years Eve. So why spend money on an event which is just a parochial pyrotechnic extravaganza?
User ID not verified.
I am a big supporter of the ABC but the coverage was awful. Pixelated fireworks at strange angles (not gun barrel harbour views) and terrible comedians. Tom Ballard’s helicopter gags were just baffling. The hosts weren’t too bad and I liked the trivia components but the whole thing definitely had an amateur hour vibe. I agree it wasn’t the time or place to mention the ABC cuts.
What would have been better would be great musical performances, some of the ABC’s top reporters talking about their year and some genuinely funny stand up acts.
I don’t really want Karl Stefanovic either. Maybe SBS can do a better job?
User ID not verified.
@TheFacts hear hear.
User ID not verified.
It’s not like the commercial networks have done any better. At least they tried to make their own content for the broadcast, instead of cutting to music videos or a Micheal Buble concert like the commercial networks have done. Maybe next year, just show the fireworks and not the 2 hours of filler. But I guess they’re are always going to be those people who resent not being able to profit of a publicly funded event.
User ID not verified.
Next year put Will.i.am in a spinning chair and people will love it.
User ID not verified.
Sorry StickToTheFacts I thought the @TheFacts post was facts free zone.
User ID not verified.
It was not very well produced or scripted…was different but I did enjoy the pub quiz segments.
Not a big fan of Julia Zemiro
User ID not verified.
Totally agree with Pea Green “Zameiro ruins everything she touches. She is puerile and full of herself”
Time to get her off TV period. So preoccupied with herself and not one bit humourous.
As for the ABC and its NYE producers – last year I felt they should have been sacked. They certainly did not take last year’s feedback on board and dished up the same embarrasing rubbish second time around.
So much for any market research let alone social media backlash.
User ID not verified.
Once again the Liberal Party social media division lands at Mumbrella to push the party line
User ID not verified.
@46 seems to be a lot of it of late
User ID not verified.
The telecast was a disgrace. Second rate comediens with 3rd rate jokes. If this is the best the ABC can do maybe the cuts need to go deeper.
User ID not verified.
Aweful commentary, music and general event aired. Clearly not as SAVVY as commercial any wonder there are cuts. A world class event only to be let down by TV station ….watched by all aroud the globe. Was not advertised leading up to the event to say FIREWORKS on ABC. We had friends watching TCN 9 thinking it would be on there.
Pity. Sorry guys but it is what it is.
FIZZER
User ID not verified.
Julia Zemiro is spectacular as the host of Australia’s Eurovision broadcast on SBS. Her and Sam Pang make a fabulous team.
User ID not verified.
Hang on @Barbara, it’s the ABC’s fault that your friends watched the wrong station?
User ID not verified.
Birdman ..not at all but it’s all about PR.
Enough said I think.
User ID not verified.
Anything is better than Richard Wilkins being wheeled out.
User ID not verified.
I too wasn’t aware ABC had sole rights but managed to jag it on the night. I’m an old ABC fan, always have been but that NYE coverage was rubbish, ABC can do better.
Parading smart-mouthed, unfunny & little-known wannabes is not the ABC way.
A video summary of Australia in 2014 would have been nice with maybe some comedic moments well- placed for balance.
We all know it’s true: a commercial channel would use this space to constantly flog other programs and even run banner ads throughout. This event deserves zero ads. Come on ABC you can do it!
User ID not verified.
Fireworks coverage for each state featuring fireworks in their own cities is preferred. Sydney is not my home town, and is not “my ABC”.
There’s no need for exclusive rights for one channel. Bring back the competition!
User ID not verified.
The Seven Network did local fireworks coverage for Melbourne but it was pretty lame (apart from the actual fireworks) and real nobody TV presenters
User ID not verified.
Finally, commenter #53, Stuart, nails it. We know what the alternative is, it’s Richard Wilkins, there’s years (maybe even decades) of old shows to go and watch if you want to see what that’s like.
ABC’s coverage reached OK in a few patches. Some really was terrible and there was a lot of fairly desperate ad-libbing in-between to try to hold it together. But then 1 in 10 of them had just got the chop.
User ID not verified.
Too many leftie oh poor ABC with it’s bum hanging out of its trousers jokes for my liking and as for that bloke in the helicopter – in the imortal words of The Simpsons’ Ms Krabappel, “Pretty lame Milhouse.”
If they do get it again maybe try a non funny person, ie not a comedian so they can link segments. That’s why the commercial stations don’t use Mick Molloy or Dave Hughes. Boring as Wilkins, Koch, Doyle, Stefanovic, Wilkinson et al are, they are professional hosts.
If things are that dire at the ABC, maybe they shouldn’t bid for gigs like this, instead putting money where it’s needed.
User ID not verified.