Courier Mail claims headlines didn’t intend to diminish life of transgender murder victim
The Courier Mail has said it had “no intention of diminishing” the life of transgender murder victim Mayang Prasetyo after it received a huge backlash to its headlines and coverage of the killing in yesterday’s paper.
The Queensland tabloid covered the murder of Prasetyo by her chef boyfriend Marcus Volke with the front page splash “Monster chef and the she male” and inside headline “Ladyboy and the butcher”, sparking an online Change.org petition which has now garnered more than 21,000 signatures and complaints to the Australian Press Council.
Today the News Corp paper acknowledged the backlash in a statement at the bottom of another article, saying: “Many believe that yesterday we presented Mayang’s story in a way that was disrespectful to her memory. The Courier-Mail had no intention of diminishing the value of Mayang’s life, or to add to the grief being felt by her family.”
Today the paper ran with the front page splash ‘Psycho gigolo’ claiming Volke was a globetrotting male prostitute before arriving in Australia.
The Change.org petition accuses the article of “trivialising” or attempting to “justify” Prasetyo’s murder.
“Rather than persecuting the offender in this case it appears that Courier Mail is attempting to justify or trivialise Mayang’s murder on the basis of her transgender status,” the petition says.
“The transgender community experience some of the highest levels of violence in any minority and the propagation, scandalisation and trivialisation of stories like this which diminish a horrific domestic violence crime to a focus on transsexualism (which for the record is no longer the appropriate terminology) does nothing but perpetuate this violent cycle”.
The Press Council’s general principles include instructions to “avoid causing or contributing materially to substantial offence, distress or prejudice, or a substantial risk to health or safety, unless doing so is sufficiently in the public interest.”
Earlier this year, the guidelines superceded the previous general principles which included an instruction that “Publications should not place any gratuitous emphasis on the race, religion, nationality, colour, country of origin, gender, sexual orientation, marital status, disability, illness, or age of an individual or group.”
The APC is the self-regulating body appointed to oversee reporting standards for Australia’s news mastheads. A spokesman for the APC said he could not comment on the case as it would now have to be assessed by the Council but confirmed it had received at least one complaint.
Nic Christensen
Of course they didn’t. They were disrespectful, homophobic, bogan, prurient, racist, and cheap but they didn’t mean any harm. Hopefully they earn all the respect for this rag that is deserves.
User ID not verified.
They didn’t mean to diminish her life but they used an extremely offensive term. And where is he actual apology in the statement? All I see is “people for some reason think it was offensive. We didn’t mean it to. Oh well.”
Here’s a better statement Courier Mail: we unreservedly apologise for our grossly offensive headline in yesterday’s paper. We have taken action against those who were involved with the headline and have put into place measures that would stop such offensive material from appearing again.”
User ID not verified.
The level of silence on this matter from News Corp and The CM is astounding. They have been constantly tweeting and posting other items on FB but have not mentioned their abhorrent front page once.
And today, during Mental Health Awareness Week, they have a massive headline on the front page using the term ‘Psycho’!
Hate to imagine what tomorrow’s front page will show…
User ID not verified.
How dare tabloid newspapers behave in a tabloid manner!
User ID not verified.
a clinically insane person who killed his mother 10 years ago escaped his institution in perth yesterday.Id love to see the headline if it happened in Brisbane
User ID not verified.
Does selling papers mean so much that News Corp abandon every ounce of integrity to achieve it? One can only imagine the CM editorial team backslapping and high fiving on a job well done. Where’s your self respect News Corp?
User ID not verified.
Forget petitions. Does anyone who signs a petition actually read the paper? Unlikely.
If the page views are up, advertising dollars continue to flow in.
Stop reading and you’ll ensure their indecency costs them through advertising losses and ultimately job losses. That’ll bring about the necessary change.
It’s a business where only money matters. Hit ’em where it hurts. It’s really that simple.
User ID not verified.
never does an anonymous comments board fill up faster than when conservative media is seen to be acting inappropriately.
User ID not verified.
The fact you are from Queensland is no longer an excuse!
User ID not verified.
More lies from the publisher that lives by them. They did exactly what they intended to do and that was to feed the bogans who read it
User ID not verified.
Is the Courier Mail trying to dress up like the NT News? OMG Bogans in Queensland who would have thought?
User ID not verified.
I have been scrolling up and down trying to find the ratings report today but could not find it. Is there a better way of presenting each segment?
User ID not verified.
Hi Hilary,
The ratings report from today is here: https://mumbrella.com.au/insight-nearly-doubles-audience-marijuana-special-255432
Cheers,
Alex- editor, Mumbrella
A shameful act by a shameful “news” paper. How does anyone call themselves a journalist and continue to write for this disgusting publication.
Money grubbing bastards
User ID not verified.
Here’s a handy Chrome extension
https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/murdoch-block/moepiacmhnmbiilhpojodnaopndhddpg
User ID not verified.
#sorrynotsorry
User ID not verified.
My Brisbane friends refer to The Courier Mail as The Curious Smell.
User ID not verified.
100% poor taste. And not the smartest sidebar positioning for “QLDs Best Food Secrets” either, perhaps?
User ID not verified.
I agree with
Bem
8 Oct 14
11:30 am
Here’s a better statement Courier Mail: we unreservedly apologise for our grossly offensive headline in yesterday’s paper. We have taken action against those who were involved with the headline and have put into place measures that would stop such offensive material from appearing again.”
User ID not verified.
Teamed up with the Wicked camper van crowd – a winning combo of cretins!
User ID not verified.
Is there a more obnoxious, sexist, racist, bigoted, biased, pig-ignorant and outright shameful media organisation in the western world than News Corp? Not that I know of. It’s an embarrassment and blot on the landscape.
User ID not verified.
Please, spare me all this sanctimonious politically-correct hand-wringing over a “poor taste” headline. I’ve seen far worse headlines and coverage from both News and Fairfax in 25 years in the media. Like Fairfax’s recent anti-Israeli cartoon featuring a hook nosed Jew bombing Gaza with a remote control.
The Mail was always going to cover this story ‘cos it has all the elements of a good local yarn, and they’re in the business of selling newspapers. Simple stuff.
User ID not verified.
Good to see the old subs from “The Truth” have found work.
User ID not verified.
Last week’s cover with the three muppets from the ridic senate enquiry (shown as monkeys) was way funnier!
User ID not verified.
And “Psycho Gigolo” is supposed to be a step in the right direction for the follow up coverage?
Chris Dore you’re nothing but an overpaid troll.
Pull your head out and stop wasting yours and everybody else’s time. This is pure brain rot. You must be so proud at the end of a day.
User ID not verified.
Oh, Chuck, I never heard a bad word about them when they were backing Kevin07.
User ID not verified.
Hard to imagine how CM could’ve been judged Newspaper of the Year if these are the editorial standards which the masthead is known for.
Give your readers a bit more credit CM – it may be a good story but spare them the bigoted, homophobic, cruel treatment you have seen fit to dish out
User ID not verified.
So, whats actually wrong with the headline.
User ID not verified.
It’s interesting the level of condemnation of the Courier Mail headlines, and rightfully so, but when the ABC allowed transphobic tweets to be seen during a Q and A broadcast with panellist Cate McGregor, the condemnation was less enthusiastic. Less than a decade ago the Sydney Morning Herald, a Fairfax newspaper, ran sensationalized anti-gay, anti-transgender content in a number of stories – few complained. During the first ever Mardi Gras in 1978, the SMH even published the names and addresses of those arrested in an attempt to publicly name and shame participants for being gay.
I actually found what the ABC did more offensive – 1) the ABC were not trying to sell a story, so there was no reason to broadcast those tweets which were moderated 2) the tweets were seen by a far bigger audience, not just readers in Queensland 3) The Courier Mail headlines did not condemn Mayang for transitioning, one of the ABC tweets seen claimed what Cate McGregor did was against God 4) The Courier Mail addressed Mayang as “she”, two of the tweets on the ABC referred to Cate McGregor as a “he”.
What Courier Mail did was wrong but I suspect transphobia is being used by some to simply attack News Limited, while transphobia by the ABC and Fairfax is swept under the carpet by those same people because to do so would mesh against their own political views.
User ID not verified.