It’s time to stop undervaluing social media managers
Some companies think they can hire a social media manager who doubles as a writer, designer, strategist, SEO expert and data analyst. But they shouldn't have too much experience, so they can be paid at a grad level. Quiip's Amber Robinson explains why we have to start taking social media managers seriously, and pay them what they're worth.
Now hiring: Writer, social strategist, graphic designer, campaign manager, project manager, community manager, SEO expert and data analyst. Ideally, we’d also like a web developer.
Here’s the catch: It’s all one job. And we want someone with only one to two years’ industry experience, so we don’t have to pay you much.
It might sound absurd, but recently I saw a job advertisement, with a similar job description, from a large Australian company seeking a social media manager.
Rarely anywhere else in the media landscape would you employ a copywriter or graphic artist who was also a Jedi master at data and analytics. But because so many tasks can be pushed under the ‘social media’ umbrella, some employers think they can all be done by one insanely talented young graduate.
One person with all the skills sounds good on paper but is hard to find.
And I’ll bet you 100 bucks that if some sucker does take the role, they’ll leave in six months due to burnout. Or, they’ll only manage a third of the tasks on their impossibly long job description, leading to frustrations all round.
The tasks involved in running a suite of social media channels range from content creation (images, text and video), to comment moderation, audience development and community management, customer service and analytics. That’s just for an organic social presence.
Throw paid social into the mix and you’ll need someone adept at media planning and buying and campaign management.
Yet the average salary for social media managers sits at just $59,535, which is a good 42% lower than the median Australian wage of $84,661. You’d pay a lot more for a campaign manager or creative director, so why are social managers who do all of these things so undervalued?
It can’t be their work ethic.
Because social media never sleeps (and evenings are the most active time for social audiences), overtime and overwork are rife. The recent 2019 Australian Community Managers Career Survey found that 77% of community managers worked more than eight hours per day and 32% reported overwork and burnout.
Social media work also carries an emotional toll, especially for online community managers, who can moderate some of the worst material on the internet.
These examples paint a bleak picture, but there is a lot to love about social media work – the variety, positive engagement with community members, and option to work from home in pyjamas are just a few.
But they can only do that with the budget, time and resources to do their jobs properly. To put it bluntly – it’s time we took social media seriously.
Amber Robinson is a social media strategist at Quiip
Great article, Amber!
I was originally hired in a social media manager role and I burnt out very quickly. This sums up a lot of how I know people in these positions feel – especially when it comes to low recognition and salary packages for the immense amount of work.
Thanks for writing this!
User ID not verified.
Social media is fast becoming a non-productive money pit. Pay-to-play required very little in the way of ability. Many C-Suiters suspect it will be just another paid advertising platform within a few years and don’t trust the rosy engagement ‘data’ coming from the platforms. The pay and status of social media staff reflect this.
User ID not verified.
I come from a social background and I agree that, given the wide ranging scope of the role (which has got even bigger since I was working as a SMM) that they are underpaid.
However, I would encourage social media managers to find a role for themselves elsewhere. Social Death is taking it to extremes with their comment above but I’d definitely say being a jack-of-all-trades with a focus on one particular group of channels is a dangerous spot to be in. You’re spread so thinly across so many disciplines (Account management, strategy, creative, production, customer service, digital development etc) that your expertise in each is somewhat thin. And as a new generation of suits, planners, creatives, producers, designers etc come through, who have deeper expertise in their area, as well as social channel knowledge, I think the social department will become a thing of the past. Your chance is to get ahead now. Swim upstream into creative or planning or design or whatever, and carve out your place now, before they arrive.
User ID not verified.
Hey, Im paid ok!
User ID not verified.
I love this article from Amber, it reveals an uncomfortable paradox at the heart of social:
1) Our business needs to have a share of voice on social, because our competitors are smashing it online
2) Social media is ‘easy’ so no need to pay an expert
3) Oops, our social strategy has failed. Let’s bring in another candidate with little experience and underpay them. But if they have experience, let’s still underpay them and overwork them too. Rinse, repeat.
The crazy thing about this situation – never before in the history of social marketing has it been easier to measure everything in a social powered marketing campaign. That’s IF your complete digital marketing lab has been set up correctly from the start by an experienced team. How many people who advertise for social media managers even know what a digital marketing lab is?
People who say social media is a waste of time suffer from shortsightedness and a lack of knowledge.
User ID not verified.
“digital marketing lab” … a just made up phrase?
User ID not verified.
Thank you Amber for writing this article and very timely that I came across it.
I have started my digital marketing + social media management consultancy and the times I have the justify myself on my pricing is ridiculous.
We still have a long way for people to understand the value that social media can bring for brands and businesses beyond the number of likes.
It’s time that social media managers band together and stand our ground for our worth.
User ID not verified.
Thank you Amber for putting this so eloquently. So much responsibility for reputation of the organisation/brand lies with our social media managers, they’re expected to be on top of things 24/7, and get paid a pittance.
User ID not verified.
It’s not always the case that one person does everything. Our coordinator implements (read: posts) our social campaigns, but everyone in the team has usually had an input, from our writer to our marketing and comms people and also our web head. And in the case of paid posts, our media people get involved too.
User ID not verified.
Hi David,
“Digital marketing lab” is a phrase with meaning:
https://digivizer.com/digiverse/taking-you-beyond-experimentation-to-better-results-faster-changes-happier-customers/
Regards,
Tim
User ID not verified.
PREACH IT!
User ID not verified.
You’re right that paid social media is just another paid channel.
Pay-to-play does pose a risk for emerging brands in particular, which is why, at Quiip, we work with many organisations to set up owned platforms (forums etc) to keep the social IP with the organisation.
User ID not verified.
Good advice, Josh! It never hurts to specialise, and gain some skills outside social for a more integrated marketing future,
User ID not verified.
If you can’t measure it, you can’t improve it!
The measurability of social is one reason I love it. But yes – you need to know what metrics are meaningful. Thanks for the comment Tim.
User ID not verified.
That’s good to hear Jacqui, I am sure it makes for better results too.
User ID not verified.
“Being an expert in Social Media is like being an expert at taking the bread out of the refrigerator. You might be the best bread-taker-outer in the world, but you know what? The goal is to make an amazing sandwich, and you can’t do that if all you’ve done in your life is taken the bread out of the fridge.”
My social hires always have to have broader comms and public affairs knowledge.
User ID not verified.