We’ve had a data breach… let’s not tell anyone
Crisis comms expert Tony Jaques details the missteps made by New Zealand petrol company Z Energy, and explains where it all went wrong.
It’s a basic question in the face of a data breach: do we fix it and keep quiet? Or do we tell the world and risk the consequences. A major fuel company was recently confronted by this challenge, and their response and how they communicated it provides a worrying lesson for issue and crisis managers everywhere.
In November 2017, an unnamed person alerted New Zealand petrol company Z Energy that a “critical flaw” in its online fuel card system potentially exposed customer records, including names, vehicle registration details, where and when they bought petrol and, in some circumstances, even their home address.

How many more crisis comms articles before we hit the singularity?
Hi Mumbrella,
Reporter is Paula Penfold. Not Paul.
Hi Matt,
Thanks for flagging and apologies for the error. I have fixed this.
Vivienne – Mumbrella
If you imagine that anyone is willingly disclosing breaches when they think they can get away with not disclosing them, oh boy.