TV ad of the month shortlist: Carlton Draught; ‘Dickhead’; Earth Choice, Honda; TED
The finalists for the first round of Mumbrella’s TV ad of the month award can today be revealed.
The shortlist includes two controversial ads – the Carlton Draught “Tingle” ad by Clemenger BBDO Melbourne which was pulled after a few days by the brewer’s senior management and the “Don’t Be A Dickhead” road safety ad for VicRoads.
As we reported last week, the competition will each month seek out the best video ads that launched in any given month. Because March was the first month of the competition, we have also allowed leeway for ads that first ran in late February.
The shortlist has been drawn up based on self nominations, Mumbrella’s own choices and reader submissions. The winners are decided by Mumbrella readers.
This is the first time I’ve seen any of these… my telly isn’t on very much.
I think I turned it on last october.
I bought Earth Choice detergent last week because of the ad. It worked.
EarthChoice Ad really upset me when I first saw it but made me feel proud I already used it!
How about adding (f) None of the above?
Earth Choice first, daylight second
Defo earth choice, it really made me watch the ad and think about the brand and what it stands for, very rare!
I can’t believe that dreadful Carlton ad made the cut – WORST AD EVER!! Loved the Honda ad though, Earthchoice second
Definitely EARTH CHOICE! I am transfixed every time I watch it. A big idea that is powerfully emotive and compelling.
oo , I only get shit ads from SCT. These look good.
Earth Choice for my vote – it actually made me stop and think about my kitchen and laundry detergent. Plus, the execution and creative idea was excellent and definitely to brief.
Earth Choice gets my vote – nicely done.
I still think it’s funny that the Dickhead “Facebook” ad is showing Twitter, not FB, on the laptop.
Yeh like the Earth Choice one but reminds me too much of that one with the chicken being rubbed all over the kitchen for some kitchen wipes or another.
The Earth Choice ad for sure. It must be the first ad in years that has actually disgusted me for the right reasons.
I love both ads, the Earthchoice and the Honda ads…
I cant decide which one to vote…
The earthchoice really moves u to care about the environment..
while the Honda ads really inspire me to dare to dream big…
good job for both ads…
Earth Choise gets my vote – eyecatching and achieves objectives
earth’s choice definitely the pick.
sick of extra dry ads that make no sense, and don’t actually ‘say’ anything. feels like i’m being yelled at in another language
I like the earth choice ad too but it’s a real pity the earth choice product is not as pure as the ads portray.
From seeing the ads I did a bit of research and found
Flinders Uni Data Sheet for Earth Choice Dishwashing liquid
http://www.flinders.edu.au/sha.....eName=ehlt
Scroll down to see aquatic toxicity for the Soduim benzene
http://www.pesticideinfo.org/D.....Id=PC33286
Info on toxicity of Socium Laurel Sulphate.
http://www.chooseorganics.com/.....ulfate.htm
Do you think the reality doesn’t matter as long as the creative is good?
Another vote for Earth Choice.
Thanks for your comments on all the ads, which are extremely welcome, and do remember to click the survey box at the bottom of the story too.
Cheers,
Tim – Mumbrella
Earth choice by far. CRV 2nd – it has a good feeling as did the last CRV execution did a few years ago.
To be fair the TED spot is a teaser for a much bigger campaign.
The others are stand alone ads.
With that said, I’ll go the Carlton ad.
I saw the Earth Choice ad & promptly went to a local Greek restaurant so I could eat an octopus. Not sure if that was the objective but it worked for me.
I just found out about this comp – so I guess we are too late to enter Lifeline’s new community service announcements that were launched in March. Would we have been in the short list?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P56i2uqG2Rk and
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T4MyqnEBE-E
Earth Choice was my pick – very moving ad.
Earth Choice #1