Do better retail advertising, or don’t do it at all
In this guest posting – 24 hours after the closure of The Colorado Group – Jason Rose, MD of adboss.com.au, issues a rallying cry to the industry to get serious about retail advertising.
Having worked in agencies, I know there is one type of brief creatives always avoided: anything with the word ‘retail’ in it. If it related to a sale or a clearance or involved a percentage off, the view was it would be tedious and contribute zero to your folio. And you could always tell such a brief was floating around because suddenly even the slackest creative looked flat out on other things.
Well, I would like to issue a call to our industry. Forget about putting the finishing touches on that Cannes entry. The most pressing challenge our industry currently faces – and where a whole lot more creative energy needs to be focused – is how to start doing compelling retail advertising. Because right now, it’s not happening.
The hard sell
You certainly don’t need me to catalogue the challenges traditional retailers are facing. Low consumer confidence. Cost-of-living pressures. The high dollar. And the seemingly inexorable shift to online, with both traditional e-commerce and now group-buying websites, is forcing many retailers into great difficulty if not all the way into administration.
The game is changing rapidly and irreversibly and yet the retail advertising you see is exactly the same as it was 15 years ago. It’s all about yelling product and price and using the same gimmicks and tricks that were around in the 1950s and probably earlier. Unfortunately, today’s retailers and their agencies are fighting the last war when the enemy was the store down the road and all you had to do was convince consumers your range and prices were better.
Those days are gone, and if what I am seeing is the best retailers and their agencies can do, my advice is, honestly, to stop advertising. Save your money. All that most of the current retail advertising that I see does is provide consumers with a nicely laid out catalogue to compare products online. Stop advertising. At least then consumers might be forced to visit your store to check out your prices.
So, what are retailers to do?
Obviously, the answer needs to take in far more than just advertising. But in terms of communications, this is the very question that should be occupying the sharpest minds in the business. And this should not only be motivated by the intellectual challenge. Without local, real-world retailers – large and small – there will be far less money finding its way into ad agency pay packets.
How each retailer responds to these challenges will vary. However, the key question they and their agencies need to answer is exactly the same: why should someone shop here?
For some retailers, the answer may be found in reacquainting themselves and their customers with their own brands. Remember them? It pains me to see formerly prestigious, up-market retailers advertising their wares like they were discount retailers. A store loses so much of its magic when its advertising is crammed full of products and prices and loud headlines and has absolutely no soul, no exclusivity.
Compare this all-too-common approach with the consistently beautiful work of, say, Harvey Nichols in the UK.
Other retailers may find the answer in and around the benefits of face-to-face retailing itself: The provision of expert knowledge or the ability to try things on or having the comfort of knowing there is a real store with real people that you can take things back to if there is a problem. I know I’ve been stung by previously thinking that that last point was irrelevant.
Yes, I know all of these directions are category propositions, but they are important and have the potential to be powerful and ownable if they are communicated in a fresh and unique way. At the very least, they need to be alive in people’s minds when they are considering their next purchase and are about to reflexively jump onto the net.
No-one said it would be easy
The challenges for retailers and their agencies are clearly there. But there is one thing that I know. People love shopping.
People love finding things, picking things up, playing with them, smelling them, trying them on, asking questions, getting answers from people who love what they sell, bargaining. People like walking out of stores with their things and not having to wait for them to be delivered from overseas (and hopefully without being damaged). People love striding down the street weighed down by full shopping bags dangling off their arms.
Sadly, retail advertising so rarely captures any of these powerful feelings. Here’s our stuff. Here’s what it costs. Here’s our fake sense of urgency. Next! Thankfully, the era in which this approach is good enough is gone and hopefully that inspires retailers and their agencies to create far more compelling approaches to get people away from their computers and into the stores.
Helping to solve this problem would be a demonstration of the craft of advertising at its best. It’s a big challenge and one that should inspire even the most retail-phobic of agency people.
Jason Rose is the joint MD of adboss.com.au
Australian retail is one of the few instances where the advertising is perfectly aligned with the product offering. Unfortunately they are embarrisingly both piss poor.
Harvey Nicols invests in it’s brand via advertising, merchandising, store experience and also has invested in an ecommerce store that sells brands that 30-40% cheaper than our dept stores. We have our own Harvey N”s in Australia however the retail experience is slightly different.
User ID not verified.
Wise words Jason. There is a great opportunity for retail advertising to be smart and humourous in Australia.
The Colorado Group hasn’t closed… just the Colorado stores and a few stores from some of their other chains..
User ID not verified.
Good article Jason.
There is, I think, a fundamental reason why many retailers fail to produce good creative work. Its because they do advertising not marketing. There is a big difference.
Advertising is the combination of words and pictures based on what can be said about the current offering. Marketing is about positive, customer focused actions that allow the retailer to differentiate themselves and therefore provide the raw material for creative inspiration…and great advertising.
This lesson of marketing 101 has been brought to you today TOTALLY FREE – more lessons at 50% OFF!…apply to….
User ID not verified.
Derek – I think you’re warm.
My view is that most Australian retail brands view their press advertising as a “brochure on a page” – almost literally. They’re selling a price over an aspiration (which is left to the brand) – they have commoditised themself and then wonder why customers become fickle.
User ID not verified.
It’s perfectly possible to do great work in retail just as it is in any other category; I’m please to say I’ve been involved in some pretty good examples where the needs of brand building, customer engagement AND retail sales results were pretty well balanced. But as with any category, great retail work takes a level of shared commitment, balls, imagination, innovation and partnership by both agency and client.
And there’s the rub. Back when I ran retail agency The Ideas Group the push from clients was almost always to the default position of yell and sell. I can’t tell you how many times, clients said to me “well it works for Gerry”.
That was back then when Gerry (Harvey) couldn’t put a foot wrong results-wise. Now of course it’s very clear that it’s NOT working for Gerry – although that hasn’t (yet?) affected his advertising one jot of course!
And it’s not working for a number of other yell and sell retailers. Because in the age or permission marketing, of user generated content, of targeted messaging how on earth COULD that intrusive form of customer abuse work?
The problem is, Gerry (and the like) created a very unimaginitive default position for all retailers to ‘aspire’ to. This position ignored # Derek’s valid point that it’s no longer about ‘advertising’ per se, it ignored the power of the internet, it ignored marketing technology entirely in fact.
The resultant lack of innovation has been terribly damaging to the retail industry which has finally woken up to what was so obvious to the rest of us for a number of years – multi-channel retailing requires a whole new set of rules, both operationally and in terms of marketing.
Now that the retailers are awake, perhaps agencies which are not so dumb as to reject anything with the word ‘retail’ in it have a window of opportunity to lead retailers to new forms of marketing which effectively integrate online, offline and in-store channels . Leave your sledgehammers at the door.
User ID not verified.
Harvey Nic’s latest sale campaign shows how to do it – http://goo.gl/DdlmJ
User ID not verified.
Now Harvey Nicols, that is retail advertising.
And fuck me, if I haven’t heard that “but Gerry does it” refrain myself enough times.
To which the response is: But you aren’t Gerry Harvey and your business isn’t Harvey Norman, so why would you want to risk being a limp me-too?
User ID not verified.
For 15 years now I’ve been writing retail TV and print campaigns in agencies around town, constantly under pressure by clients to yell and sell-out. The problem I come up against is this that cheap looking /sounding ads suggest cheap prices. And isn’t retail about price? Well actually it isn’t. Otherwise the battle is over and shopping online has our smoked and shrunken heads on a stick. Jason pointed at the solution with his comment about the magnetism of the real life market place. People want to dress up in their good gear and hangout with people. And until something new, and actual, comes along it’s going to be at the shops. Retailers now have to sell the product and the pleasure of actually going out and buying it. Why aren’t we seeing retailers pooling resources to create national campaigns selling the pleasure of shopping? It’s a great product with its mental and physical health benefits. To the many pleasures Jason mentioned let me add escapist lighting, instant gratification and fawning sales people calling you sir just because you walked into the shop. Not going to happen anywhere else. Get the government to cough up. And let’s all put some thinking into how to make shopping more pleasurable. The tree can uproot and run off chasing departed birds, or it can grow berries to attract them back.
User ID not verified.