Choppergate: News director resigns and Nine fires three journalists for faking live crosses
Three journalists involved in faking a live cross to the Nine News chopper have tonight been fired, and the network’s Queensland news director Lee Anderson has resigned.
Melissa Mallet, who took part in Saturday’s faked cross, and Cameron Price who was in the helicopter when it was repeated on Sunday, have both been dismissed.
Nine News Queensland’s producer Aaron Wakeley has also been sacked over the incident labelled by the network’s rivals as “Choppergate”.
The departure of Anderson – a veteran Nine news staffer who led its coverage of the Queensland flood disaster – will come as a major blow for the network.
In both incidents, viewers were told the chopper was hovering near the search for murdered teenager Daniel Morcombe. In reality, on Saturday it was hovering near Nine’s Brisbane HQ, while on Sunday it was parked on the helipad with the lights turned off so viewers could not tell it was on the ground.
Sunday’s faked cross was the first to be revealed by Mumbrella, after video footage shot by a rival network came to light of the Nine News chopper on the helipad.
Nine initially told Mumbrella that it had been ordered to touch down by air traffic control because of bad weather and the producer was unaware until it was too late.
However, it then emerged that air traffic flight data suggested the Nine chopper had been nowhere near Beerwah during a live cross the previous day when weather was fine.
In both cases weekend host Eva Milic was presenting the bulletin.
Last night the network apologised to its viewers in a message read by weeknight co-presenter Melissa Downes.
This evening Nine released a statement to Mumbrella saying:
QTQ Director of News, Lee Anderson, tendered his resignation today, and three Nine employees have been dismissed in the wake of the misrepresentation by Nine News of QTQ helicopter’s location during two live reports last weekend.
Further, newsroom procedures and lines of communication have been reviewed, resulting in immediate changes to QTQ’s news gathering guidelines. All News staff will receive further training on their editorial, legal and code obligations
These actions follow a full internal investigation of the incidents ordered by Nine Network Managing Director, Jeffrey Browne, and conducted this week by Nine Queensland Managing Director, Kylie Blucher and Nine’s Director of News and Current Affairs, Mark Calvert.
In a letter today Mr. Anderson said “This morning I tender my resignation as Director of News accepting full responsibility for the events of the last few days. I have served this network to the best of my ability for almost 25 years. It has been a privilege and I wish the team all the very best.”
Subsequently, Nine management dismissed Nine News Reporters Cameron Price and Melissa Mallet, and QTQ News Producer Aaron Wakely.
Kylie Blucher and Mark Calvert said in a joint statement:
“This has obviously been a very difficult process, but our primary consideration was always Nine News’ commitment to accuracy. This is critical not only to our charter, but to maintaining the trust we have developed with our audience over a very long period. “
While Mr. Anderson’s resignation was accepted, and his decision was the right one in the circumstances, they acknowledged his long and distinguished service with Nine.
Jeffrey Browne said: “Our position is unequivocal. We rightly demand accountability and high standards of others, and we must meet those expectations ourselves. Over the weekend, we did not. Our clear determination is to ensure that sort of conduct is never repeated, and we have drawn a very clear line in the sand by removing the staff involved in in that breach of trust with our viewers.”
Cameron Price joined Nine in 2008 after a stint with WIN. He has a BA in journalism from the University of Queensland.
Melissa Mallet also joined Nine in 2008 after a stint at WIN during which time she was also crowned Miss Toowoomba Showgirl, her Nine profile states. She studied a BA in journalism at QUT, where she won young student metro journalist of the year in the Queensland Media Awards.
There was no word in the statement about weekend presenter Eva Milic – a former model and Miss World Australia – who conducted both live crosses. She has a Master of Journalism and Mass Communication degree from Griffith University. Most of her on air career has been as a weather presenter.
Nine veteran Lee Anderson was given his current brief almost exactly a year ago when Kylie Blucher was named MD of Channel Nine Queensland.
Earlier this year Anderson took part in a NineMSN livestream during which he talked about how the network uses its choppers for newsgathering.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VqiP48kKzyY
The timing of Choppergate is particularly poor for Nine because the network has just begun to air a promotion based around it being the network to trust.
ends
You’ve accidentally spelt it Aaaron instead of Aaron: http://twitter.com/#!/Aaron_Wakeley
User ID not verified.
Ta, spellchecker – if we’ve learned anything these last 72 hours, it’s the importance of accuracy…
Cheers,
Tim – Mumbrella
Blimey.
User ID not verified.
Did you break the original story Tim? And, if so, are these Mumbrella’s first scalps?
User ID not verified.
Hi Jeff,
We may have been first to post the original story. I suspect I wasn’t the only journalist chasing it at the time.
Scalps is a bit triumphalist. I’ve never met Lee Anderson, but tonight I’ve been watching the behind the scenes live streams he did with NineMSN which are up on YouTube. Strikes me he’s a serious news guy, who did great things during the floods. He’s taken responsibility, but I’m not sure that necessarily makes it his fault.
Not a good way for anybody to end a career.
Cheers,
Tim – Mumbrella
Not sure how I feel about the sackings. Seems harsh, yet they must be seen to take decisive action. Maybe a suspension would have been more appropriate? Could it lead to an unfair dismissal action?
User ID not verified.
“We rightly demand accountability and high standards of others, and we must meet those expectations ourselves”
Except when it comes to ACA it seems :p
User ID not verified.
A bit harsh – surely an apology, some humble pie, and a commitment not to re-offend would have been sufficient?
User ID not verified.
According to Hugh Riminton (@hughriminton) Lee Anderson was away on leave during the entire chopper debacle and quit in disagreement with the sackings.
User ID not verified.
Yikes! It’s not like they tapped someone’s phone…
User ID not verified.
Punishment was harsh, but now that the bar has been set it will be interesting to see what other little ‘fibs’ are now revealed on rival networks.
This is hardly an isolated incident, and if getting the sack for lying to your audience is the new benchmark, then there are a couple of news programs that might not have enough staff left to make it to air…
There should be some nervous journos and news directors out there in TV land tonight!
User ID not verified.
What’s the big deal? It was dumb, but honestly, who cares?!
I too don’t understand why no one kicks and screams when ACA go to air every night with complete rubbish yet a cheap shot in a helicopter and everyone chucks their toys out the pram!
User ID not verified.
well, melissa was in the 9 chopper….IF you are in Sydney, or the Gold Coast, then the 9 studios ARE near Beerwah, as stated in the lower graphic in picture, and the chopper might have taken the shots half an hour earlier…hmmmm, I’m sure all the networks tell fibs. Or do you believe everything you see on TV?
User ID not verified.
Although he took responsibility for the whole thing, Lee was on leave the entire time and probably had no idea about what went on until he got back. He resigned in protest of the 2 young reporters and producer getting the sack. Good on him I say – morals like that will take him far wherever he ends up after this.
User ID not verified.
Dear me, look at the several comments calling it ‘harsh’ to sack a journo for faking news. That shows just how de-sensitized to this kind of fraud people have become. Of course it’s common, of course the perpetrators only get sacked on the rare occasions when they’re publicly outed, but don’t imagine that makes it acceptable.
User ID not verified.
Does seem harsh – who really cares as long as the facts of the story are there. I hardly think the other stations would be much better. Wonder if channel 7 would be so decisive in sacking their staff if the shoe was on the other foot (which I am sure it has been before).
User ID not verified.
It seems wrong to me that the most junior people in the chain copped it. And the News Director wasn’t fired because it was his fault, rather he seemed to think it was outrageous too and resigned in protest. Seems like the usual scapegoating…
User ID not verified.
Astounding that there are people thinking that it’s harsh for reporters to be fired for faking the news. I have to agree with Hugh Riminton’s comment on the subject –
“No reporter should knowingly tell a lie. Simple. Calvert was right #ch9choppergate”.
User ID not verified.
I guess if you pay people peanuts for long enough, you end up with young stupid monkeys that will ultimately turn around and bit the network in the bum. Cutting corners is not acceptable, lying to viewers is not acceptable, participating in a lie by sitting in a chopper that you’ve been told to sit in – is not acceptable. Then again, it’s a pretty stupid policy to have so many needless live crosses too! Why would you want to be in a chopper above Beerwah at night, when there was no searching happening below you anyway? Stupid decisions all round, caused by a stupid policy. Above all though, you just don’t lie to viewers, it stinks. Lee is a great loss to the network, but I wouldn’t give the other three another job – having and demonstrating ethics is crucial to the role of a fair media in a democracy – how do you recover from being a big liar?!
User ID not verified.
Surely the reporters didn’t make the editorial decisions to handle the story, or the chopper use or non use, the way it was done.
They, presumably, were doing what they were directed to do.
Nine’s management should rethink their decisions over the reporters.
The buck stops with the editorial decision maker on the day, or days, and yes, they probably should get some penance. But not sacking.
Other comments are right. All the networks’ news and current affairs programs are guilty of these sort of things at some time or other in various ways.
It doesn’t make it acceptable but sadly it is symptomatic of the increasing laziness evident in various forms of journalism these days.
Jack Dalton
User ID not verified.
How unfortunate it is to see qualified journalists compromising the quality of news, particularly with the sensitive nature of the Daniel Morcombe news story. They should be sacked, there job is to present facts in a accurate manner.
User ID not verified.
Gees I hope this accountability spreads to other media such as 2UE with the Parrot’s record!
User ID not verified.
Shame on chanel 7…..rather than their qualified university journalists…..working on stories….it seems they pay them and others in their employment good wages top
SPY ON THEIR RIVAL TELEVISION STATION CHANNEL 9…..WHAT ARE THEY AFRAID OF….’LOOSING THE RATINGS’…..I was quite disgusted to watch the Live Cross on saturdays news from channel 7 as they continuously probed Daniel Morcombe’s father for more, and more…..channel 7s journalist obviously didn’t know when to stop…..I felt very uncomfortable watching it and thought to myself ” FOR GODS SAKE….THATS ENOUGH QUESTIONING….LEAVE HIM BE”…..THAT SORT OF INSENSITIVITY SHOULD WARRANT A SACKING……SHAME ON CHANNEL 7……….CHANNEL 9s …HELICOPTERS WOULD HAVE BEEN THERE ….BOTH ON SATURDAY AND SUNDAY AS THE VISION…..SHOWED THE SEARCHING BEING CONDUCTED BELOW……..CHANNEL 9 OBVIOUSLY WANTED TO RE-CREATE TO ITS VIEWERS A BROADER STORY OF WHAT WAS HAPPENING DURING THAT DAY FROM THE CHOPPER AND USED SOME INITIATIVE TO RE-CREATE THE SCENE AND THE INTENSITY OF IT FROM THE CHOPPER…….I DO NOT SEE IT AS DECEIVING THEIR VIEWERS AT ALL…..BUT RECREATING THE SCENE ‘THAT DAY”…….AFTER ALL THEY SAID THEY WERE…….NEAR BEERWAH……NOT AT BEERWAH….
I CONGRATULATE CHANNEL 9 FOR BRINGING TO US SUCH A SENSITIVE STORY…..WHICH WAS DELIVERED WITH COMPASSION AND SENSITIVITY BY NEWSREADER…..EVA MILIC…..I WILL BE WATCHING CHANNEL 9 MORE NOW THAN BEFORE
User ID not verified.
Easy on the caps lock key there big fella
User ID not verified.
@ “Michael”
Wow… setting up a remote webcam, and pointing it at a helicopter pad is so expensive and staff intensive.
Sarcasm, if you couldn’t tell.
It would either be monitored by the staff that already watch all the other feeds that they do (that is why they are there and are paid to do), or it’s ran through a program set up to alert at major movement within view.
Neither are that difficult, expensive, or taking away from other duties of the employees…
And trust me; every network, amateur and their dog are doing exactly the same as each other.
User ID not verified.
It definitely doesn’t come at a good time for Nine, especially considering their new slogan of being the ‘news to trust’. Although I don’t understand why Channel Nine would even risk crossing over to a stationary chopper instead of actually having it where it was stating to be. In the air. And particularly around such a high profile news case as Daniel Morcombe. It just presents viewers with doubt regarding Nine’s authenticity. Even if the weather had been bad enough to prevent flight, wouldn’t stating that be better than trying to deceive the public?
User ID not verified.
Geez, what an overreaction. They weren’t fudging the facts, just lying about where they were. Does it really matter? (Sometimes I work in a cafe and pretend I’m at my desk if anyone calls me…)
User ID not verified.