AGL launches ‘do not knock’ sticker campaign while fighting legal battle against stickers
Energy supplier AGL has launched a campaign distributing hundreds of thousands of ‘do not knock’ stickers to customers while at the same time it is fighting a battle against the legal enforceability of such signs.
The brand has begun to enclose “Do not knock” stickers with its bills. If consumers put them in place, they make it more difficult for rival energy companies to persuade consumers to switch.
The move has been labelled ironic by AGL’s critics.
Just yesterday AGL was reportedly fined $1.55 million, after an AGL door-to-door seller posed as an investigations officer. AGL is also fighting the ACCC about whether ‘do not knock’ stickers are enforceable in Australian consumer law.
Sarah Wilson, senior campaigner with the Consumer Law Centre, said sticker campaign was clearly about AGL tryign to stop rival companies from getting to speak to its customers. “We would expect that it is being done to protect their market share. However, they’re not the first retailer to do it,” said Wilson.
The message from AGL tells consumers: “We know door-to-door sales people have a job to do, and we also understand you may be left alone. So you might find this sticker useful.”
On the other side of the insert, consumers are invited to come into an AGL Smarter Living store in person to pick up a “sturdy vitreous enamel sign, free of charge”. The small print says that only AGL customers can have the free sign.
Christopher Zinn, campaign director at One Big Switch, a company which markets itself on getting consumers better utilities prices, said the campaign was ironic.
“AGL are certainly ‘Johnny-come-latelys’ to the operation. If you were responsible for a lot of door knocking it is somewhat ironic to put out ‘do not knock’ stickers,” said Zinn. “I would like to think they were responding to consumer demand to help keep door knockers away but there is the perception that the big players have the most to gain.”
AGL told Mumbrella that the campaign was not self serving and said was driven by research the company had conducted.
“The reason we are doing it is in response to customer concern. People really don’t like it,” Karen Winsbury head of AGL corporate communications, told Mumbrella. “It was launched in response to research we conducted which showed our customers disliked door knocking practices.”
In March this year AGL ceased its door knocking. Zinn argues that the current campaign is an attempt by one of the major utilities players to restrict competition in the utilities sector.
“The argument against the big guys like AGL sending out ‘do not knock’ stickers has been that small players seeking to grow market share are limited in what was one of their best channels,” said Zinn.
The Consumer Law Centre’s Wilson also urged AGL to drop its current action against the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission in regards to ‘do not knock stickers’.
“If they think the sticker doesn’t work then why on earth are they doing it themselves? It doesn’t make a lot of sense, ” said Wilson. “By publishing this (campaign) they are admitting the stickers do work.”
AGL conceded there was an irony. “Look there is, and I appreciate it certainly appears that way,” said Winsbury who argued the current court action was an attempt by the company to reform current consumer law.
“As matter of law that we don’t believe the law as it is currently drafted constitutes a request to leave the premises,” she said.
“We believe it should but that is why we are arguing the case. If we lose all good it’s rock solid but if we win it means consumer law will hopefully be revised.”
Nic Christensen
As a consumer, it makes me wonder why they’re so worried I might find out about their competitor’s offers. I don’t feel like they’re doing me a favour, I don’t answer my front door anyway.
User ID not verified.
The move has been labelled as “ironic” by Alanis Morrisette too.
User ID not verified.
lol
User ID not verified.
AGL rather amusing that you needed feedback from customers that 3rd party pressure selling isn’t appreciated at the door.
Ever wonder why no other sector is doing it?
User ID not verified.
ironic indeed – and pointless.
Lumo’s the only one doing door knocking these days i gather
User ID not verified.
where oh where is the PR agency for AGL.. this poor woman is left to make senseless contradictory statements – not a good look
User ID not verified.
Cheeky bastards!
User ID not verified.
I have had about 5 people knock on my door (when I have been at home) in the last 6 months, trying to sell me something. I live in a unit block and communicate with these callers via intercom. My intercom has a video; I can see them, however they cannot see me.
I will break these ‘door knockers down’ into two groups for you:
1) Religious nutjobs
2) Energy selling nutjobs
Both parties begin their spill with “I am not trying to sell you anything”. Funny that, because both, in the long term, will (if I oblige) take my cash!
I am always polite. I ignore whatever they say and always ask them a few wayward questions; politely and calmly of course.
I start with something along the lines of: “Can you see any red cars in my street?”
Regardless of whether they reply “yes” or “no” I proceed with: “Have you ever been to France?”
Again, regardless of their answer I then move onto something I can see, through the video intercom: “Are you wearing a striped tie?” OR “Is the coat that you are wearing registered with local authorities?”
“Are you enabled for driveway clearance” usually ends the conversation.
I will always try to also get in: “Just to let you know that all conversations at this doorstep are recorded for training and compliance purposes, is that okay?”
Whilst they are departing I usually belt out the chorus of a song, like this one from 42nd St:
“We’re in the money,
We’re in the money;
We’ve got a lot of what it takes to get along!”
(I sing this as loud as I possibly can and in a high pitched accent) – I have a deep voice usually.
That is how I liaise with these people – AGL, please feel free to send your guys around whenever you like!
User ID not verified.
LOL too
User ID not verified.
To ” My experience”
youre nuts…I love you.
User ID not verified.
To ” my experience”….for some people…(the lonely or disliked ) this may be the only interaction they have with another person all day. Let’s not knock that. Look at it more of a community service in some instances.
User ID not verified.
When I was very young, a long time ago, I had a Donald Duck comic in which the nephews, Huey, Dewey and Louie, had a scheme to market little “No Hawkers or Canvassers” plaques.
They sold them door to door.
User ID not verified.
@Willy Loman
A male neighbour rang my intercom 3 weeks ago, (he had locked himself out of the unit block). I went through the usual procedure, (as mentioned above), he hasn’t spoken to me since..?
User ID not verified.