Ship Song missed out on glory in Cannes because it was ‘lost in translation’, says The Monkeys creative director
Scott Nowell
One of the most popular Australian TV ads of the last year, The Ship Song Project for the Sydney Opera House by The Monkeys, failed to make even the long list in the Film Lions at Cannes because it was “lost in translation”, says The Monkeys ECD and Cannes juror Scott Nowell.
“The lost in translation factor played a role in why it wasn’t chosen, although obviously I wasn’t in the room when the jury looked at our entry,” said Nowell.
“People don’t know the song. They don’t know the artists in the ad. And they don’t know the history of the Sydney Opera House. The significance of those things would have been completely lost on the jury.”
Nowell added that he didn’t think the ad’s similarity to the BBC Perfect Day spot was why the ad was not favoured. “It didn’t play as big a role as the lost in translation factor,” he said.
The Ship Song Project was chosen by Mumbrella as the best ad of last year in the Mumbrella Annual at Christmas time.
you don’t win gongs for work which is so derivative and rightly so.
Yes this sounds a bit pathetic and detracts from the ad which was great. Next time just take it on the chin, like a man!
User ID not verified.
And there stands the irrelevance of international award shows. Unless the intended target market is a bunch of CDs, of course. But there aren’t to may legitimate briefs that state that.
User ID not verified.
That and it was a complete rip off of the BBC ‘Perfect day’ ad Scotty.
User ID not verified.
It didn’t win because it wasn’t good. Simple.
User ID not verified.
It didn’t make the shortlist because every juror would have recognized it as being derivative of A Perfect Day. Simple really.
User ID not verified.