Opinion | Features
- With several of Australia's biggest media accounts coming up for tender and many changing hands this year David Spasovic looks at what is causing so many client-agency relationships to fracture. A cursory glance at the recent stories, opinion pieces and comments in the trade press present an image of significant rumblings of discontent in our industry. A quick count of media relationships that are or have recently been reviewed is evidence of this - Woolworths, Federal Government, Lion, Diageo, Nestle and CBA are a few accounts that fall into this category.
- As the government considers changes to national security legislation Keiran Hardy looks at what today's proposals would mean for the media if implemented, in a cross-posting from The Conversation. The Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security (PJCIS) will publish its report on the National Security Legislation Amendment Bill (No. 1) 2014 (Cth) sometime during this sitting of parliament. The bill, introduced in the last sitting of parliament, has attracted significant criticism for the potential impact of proposed offences on media outlets. The main fear, fuelled by the fallout from the WikiLeaks and Snowden affairs, is that journalists could be imprisoned for reporting intelligence abuses or mistakes revealed by a “whistleblowing” intelligence officer, even when doing so would be in the public interest.
- With publishers struggling to monetise digital and marketers unable to achieve cut through John McLean argues it's time to ditch banner ads and get collaborating. In a medium infatuated and necessitated by innovation, display advertising has been criminally bereft of it since it’s inception 20 years ago. The first banner ad appeared in Wired Magazine in 1994* and little has changed since around 2000 when rich media placements became more common due to better connection speeds.
- With Buzzfeed pushing to be recognised as a news site Ciaran Norris looks at why it matters for new online media outlets to be seen as serious. Every morning on its News Breakfast show the ABC runs through the major stories on the front pages of the day’s newspapers, covering everything from the Sydney Morning Herald to The Age, the Daily Telegraph to The Mercury. But it has also, for some time, included the homepage of the Australian version of The Guardian which differs from the rest of the organisations included because it has no printed version.
- In this cross-posting from The Conversation Michael Cowling asks whether the recent controversy over the Facebook Messenger app shows people have reached the limit of what information they're willing to give away to companies. The recent furore about the Facebook Messenger app has unearthed an interesting question: how far are we willing to allow our privacy to be pushed for our social connections? In the case of the Facebook Messenger app, the answer appears to be: “Not as far as Facebook thinks.” For those who are not yet on Facebook (yes, there are some), the social media giant has been asking all users who want to continue sending messages to their Facebook friends on their mobile devices to download a Facebook Messenger app. Facebook is preparing to stop the chat feature on its main Facebook app.
- Instant messaging is the new digital battle ground. Daniel Young looks at what impact this battle might have for the traditional social networks. The social media landscape is changing, again, and the new players are demanding brands shift their mindset - from being human to getting personal.
- In the wake of the decision by retailer Woolworths to retain Carat as its media agency, Mumbrella's Nic Christensen asks if the much-maligned pitch for the $240m account is a case study in how clients should not treat their agencies. It's funny how history has a habit of repeating itself, but you'd like to think the marketing world would occasionally learn a trick or two. Some of the decisions in the process which led to the decision by Woolworths to keep its mammoth media account at Carat certainly make you wonder what goes through the minds of some clients when they pitch.
- In this cross-posting from The Conversation science astronomer Michael J. I. Brown shares his experiences in debating with and challenging online trolls. I often like to discuss science online and I’m also rather partial to topics that promote lively discussion, such as climate change, crime statistics and (perhaps surprisingly) the big bang. This inevitably brings out the trolls. “Don’t feed the trolls” is sound advice, but I’ve ignored it on occasion – including on The Conversation and Twitter – and I’ve been rewarded. Not that I’ve changed the minds of any trolls, nor have I expected to.
- Using big data to look at past trends is not the best way to work out what your customers want, argues Peter Swan of the UNSW Australia Business School in this cross-posting from The Conversation. A passer-by happens upon a drunk searching for a lost wallet under a streetlight. With nothing in plain sight, the passer-by asks “Where did you drop your wallet?”. “Over there,” gestures the drunk across the street, “but I’m looking here because this is where the light is.”
- This has been a bad week for the newspaper industry, says Mumbrella's Tim Burrowes As far as Australian newspapers go, this has been a most disillusioning week. I love 'em - but jeez, they make it hard.
- After the tragic news of Robin Williams' death after a struggle with depression Oli Shawyer shares the story of his battle with the black dog, and how talking about it helped him beat it. The news of Robin Williams rocked me to my core yesterday. I didn’t know the man personally but there is something so profoundly tragic about a comedian, someone whose job it is to make us laugh every day, suffering so intensely. To be fair, it’s a testament to how fucked up depression really is – that it can somewhat delude a man beloved by so many people, into deciding that he is better off dead.
- In this cross-posting from The Conversation Nicholas Sheppard of Victoria University explores what measures have so far been tried, and failed, to stop copyright infringement and piracy. There’s been a bit of talk recently about getting internet service providers (ISPs) involved in the enforcement of copyright law. The federal Attorney-General and Minister for Communications recently released an Online Copyright Infringement Discussion Paper in the belief that "even where an ISP does not have a direct power to prevent a person from doing a particular infringing act, there still may be reasonable steps that can be taken by the ISP to discourage or reduce online copyright infringement". Exactly what might be “reasonable steps” and how they might be funded are among the subjects up for discussion. Critics fear that it means turning ISPs into copyright police.
- In this guest post, Darren Woolley wonders which role in an agency – creative, media, digital, planning or account management – is the most valuable to the client. In benchmarking the cost of an ad agency’s staff, you generally find that the rate a client pays is commensurate with the experience or seniority of the resource. But the question of value goes beyond just cost to determining the return on the investment. So in considering the value we need to balance the cost of the resource against how much they contribute to the ROI.
- Yesterday satirist John Oliver launched a blistering attack on native advertising describing it as "repurposed bovine waste". In this guest post, content marketing specialist Richard Parker calls bullshit on Oliver's argument. I’m usually a big fan of John Oliver. What’s not to like? The lefty credentials? The anti-Fox news stance? The fact that he’s from Birmingham? But his latest piece vilifying native advertising leaves me a bit cold.
- In recent days 'tapegate' has consumed much of the Victorian political news cycle. In this cross posting from The Conversation academic Mark Pearson looks at legalities around journalists recording sources. It is a sad day when senior political figures steal a journalist’s recording device and destroy its contents, as we have been told happened at this year’s Victorian Labor Party conference. But it is an even sadder day when we hear a major newspaper – The Age – justifying a senior reporter secretly recording their conversations with sources.
Ben Elton Live From Planet Earth dead on arrival
Comedian Ben Elton’s return to live television rated just 455,000 for Nine last night.
The debut of Live From Planet Earth is one of the bigger risks in Nine’s schedule for the start of the 2011 ratings season.
But the show was 22nd for the night and finished third in the timeslot, behind Seven’s Parenthood and Ten’s NCIS, and with just 1000 more viewers for Ben Elton than ABC1′s episode of QI, according to preliminary overnight ratings from OzTam.
A breakdown of Live From Planet Earth’s performance shows that after inheriting an average Top Gear Audience of nearly one million, viewers started fleeing immediately from a peak of 805,000.
The first 15 minutes saw the average audience fall to 633,000 – and 15 minutes later that had dropped by a dramatic 33% to 421,000. An average of just 296,000 stuck around for the final 15 minutes.
The British comedian and author – who has now settled in WA – was one of the driving forces behind the rise of alternative comedy in the 1980s. Elton’s TV writing credits includes Blackadder and The Young Ones. The show is being produced by Fremantle Media.
Meanwhile, the top end of Tuesday’s most-watched list had a familiar feel, with Seven’s Packed To The Rafters averaging a metro audience of 1.943m and My Kitchen Rules rating nearly 1.6m.
Ten’s series return of Talkin Bout Your Generation rated 831,000.
Tuesday’s top 15 shows:
- Packed to the Rafters Seven 1.943m
- My Kitchen Rules Seven 1.551m
- Today Tonight Seven 1.190m
- Seven News Seven 1.153m
- NCIS – 9:30pm Ten 1.153m
- NCIS – 8:30pm Ten 1.058m
- Home and Away Seven 1.048m
- Nine News Nine 1.042m
- A Current Affair Nine 0.966m
- Top Gear Nine 0.939m
- The Big Bang Theory Nine 0.922m
- ABC News ABC 0.871m
- Talkin’ ‘Bout Your Generation Ten 0.831m
- Parenthood Seven 0.769m
- Ten News Ten 0.752m
- Seven: 28.9%
- Ten: 19.3%
- Nine: 18.7%
- ABC1: 9.3%
- SBS1: 4.2%
- GO!: 3.2%
- 7TWO 3.1%
- Eleven: 2.8%
- Gem: 2.8%
- 7mate: 2.7%
- ABC2: 1.5%
- SBS2: 1.2%
- One: 0.8%
- ABC3: 0.7%
- ABC News 24: 0.6%
- Billy C on News quietly removes Perth Now paywall
- NH on AOL’s digital prophet: Australia is just a ‘mid-sized audience’ for Huffington Post
- Lindsay. on Kim Williams wonders what could have been if he’d stayed at ABC, criticises drama and doco output and labels print ‘doomed’
- Oh? on News quietly removes Perth Now paywall
- Oh? on Kim Williams wonders what could have been if he’d stayed at ABC, criticises drama and doco output and labels print ‘doomed’
- JD on Shine starts to fade for mummy bloggers as study indicates interest falling away
- Grant on Mike Carlton pens first column for Crikey since quitting Fairfax
- Bem on Mike Carlton pens first column for Crikey since quitting Fairfax
- Digital Planer | Health
- SEO Manager | global agency
- PR/Social Account Manager – Corporate – Inspiring Team!
- Digital Media Assistant
- SEO Consultant
- PR Senior Account Manager – B2B Tech!! Amazing International Agency! Huge Scope!!
- PR Account Director/2IC – Tech & B2B – Amazing Career Opportunity!
- Mid-Weight Designer (SYD)
- Travel Editor (SYD)
- inthemix Staff Writer (SYD)
- New management line up for 303Lowe after internal promotions
- Australian Story interviews Bondi Hipster Christiaan Van Vuuren
- Channel Nine Perth announces new AFL show
- 303Lowe picks up IMB Building Society full service account following pitch
- Commercial Radio Australia release 2014 Digital Radio Report
- King Content partners with Walkley Foundation
- Foxtel appoint Penny Win as head of drama
- The Remarkables Group announces six new bloggers to its roster
- The Scam Lions? Count me out
With 73 comments
- Fairfax commentator Mike Carlton resigns after sending abusive messages to readers
With 58 comments
- Calling bullshit on John Oliver's attack on native advertising
With 57 comments
- Ad watchdog misunderstood complaints against 'demeaning' UltraTune ad says change.org petition organiser
With 46 comments
- SMH boss Darren Goodsir asks columnist Mike Carlton to apologise for being rude to readers
With 39 comments
- Woolworths brings back 'Fresh Food People' positioning in first brand campaign from Leo Burnett
With 38 comments
- Sydney Morning Herald apologises for Jewish cartoon likened to Nazi propaganda
With 35 comments
- Mike Carlton calls Daily Telegraph 'scum of the trade' as editor apologises for photoshopping his face on Boston bombing victim
With 32 comments
- The Scam Lions? Count me out