Marketers ‘stuck in comfort zone’ amid continuing focus on clicks, shares and likes
Marketers are still not measuring the performance of their digital advertising strategies in any meaningful way with the ongoing failure branded “incredibly frustrating” by the Chief Marketing Officer Council.
CMO Council chief executive Liz Miller said she “rolls her eyes” when hearing of the metrics still being used to gauge the success of a campaign.
Marketers talk a good game and are demonstrating “bravado” but ultimately they are “stuck in their comfort zone” and continue to fall back on clicks, likes and shares, she said.
The comments came at the release of research from Adobe and the CMO Council which showed marketers are focused on digital but failing to demonstrate its worth to the bottom line. That, in turn, is preventing them from presenting a strong enough business case to receive a larger budget, the study said.
“We found that despite the knowledge that digital has a mandate for the future and a mandate for success, we are having a hard time getting there.” Miller said. “What is really holding us back is this campaign-centered approach where everything goes into a silo and into a neat little bucket-world of digital marketing where you have your website and social and your advertising and SEO.
“What we are failing to connect is how all of these individual points on the journey link back to the customer. And because we are only looking at those campaigns in a limited view we are beginning to question whether whether digital really can impact the business.”
The report said Australian marketers are still focused on “single vector metrics” that measure past success or single campaign performance rather than “harder business metrics” such as customer lifetime value.
Asked if she was surprised at the findings, Miller said: “I wish I was. That is the incredibly frustrating thing. I feel like a broken record.
“When we get CMOs in a room they say ‘we are driving the business, we are orchestrators of the customer experience’.
“Then you ask them for their top five metrics and they say cost per lead, clicks, social media metrics. You kind of have to roll your eyes a bit.
“We don’t seem to focus on those metrics of revenue and that is the only universal language of business.”
Many marketers are “stuck in the comfort zone”, Miller added, arguing they need to be more proactive about “defining what measures we want to capture that will impact the business”.
“That must happen before we execute the campaigns rather than only thinking about them when we are filling out our awards submission,” she said.
The study of almost 650 marketers across Australia and Asia Pacific found that only 16 per cent of local marketers measure truly relevant business metrics such as revenue per customer, down from 36 per cent in the 2013 survey.
Seven out of 10 are still measuring click through rates and 73 per cent are looking at response rates.
“It’s not a matter of throwing away clicks and web metrics because they are important in spot checking performance. But we have to start integrating new measures that do actually speak to the business,” Miller said.
Those marketers who are looking at bottom line metrics are far more successful in receiving larger budgets for digital marketing, the study suggests.
“Those metrics are what the CFO perks up to and you’ll be able to make those business cases,” Miller said.
She added that too many marketers are also using social media as a “fast, cheap advertising push channel” rather than one to truly engage with consumers.
Describing social as the “great experiment”, Miller said most brands in all regions are using social for self serving reasons.
“They are not engaging with people who are in social because they view it as a conversation,” she said. “Marketers regard it as a fast cheap advertising push channel. We try to go into the conversation in a horribly inauthentic way.”
The research also found the top digital priorities for Australian marketers was strengthening the digital content strategy (68 per cent), deeper customer profiling and insights (51 per cent) and social media optimisation (50 per cent).
Steve Jones
Injecting marketing into social media platforms runs counter-intuitive to providing users a good experience.
In other words, once you lot show up, the lead punters flee and eventually take everyone else with them.
Facebook’s the best example of the moment. Accounts are closing at an unprecedented rate while the advertising ramps through the roof. Have fun marketing to each other.
User ID not verified.
You can have bucketloads of likes, shares and clicks, but unless those likes, shares and clicks result in quality online comment and conversation with your customers and their wider social media network it’s all for nought.
User ID not verified.
… naught even!
User ID not verified.
Everybody referenced here is on the same drugs, just a different dosage.
The only value any advertising anywhere has is on sales – short term sales or long term sales. The problem is, nobody can accurately prove the impact of advertising on sales, so we invent intermediate measures that we think/hope/believe are de facto representatives of sales.
User ID not verified.
Totally agree, for as long as marketers are talking about clicks, likes, conversations, moments or engagements they will never be taken seriously at a senior/board level
User ID not verified.
Agree they’ll never be taken seriously at senior/board level as the majority at that level have absolutely no idea about how to use social/digital media properly, let alone how to value it.
User ID not verified.
There are 2 types of marketers. One that approaches everything from an abstract theoretical place and sees their role as an opportunity to experiment with the clients budget. The other one personally takes responsibility and ownership of the survival and growth of the clients business. Unfortunately most marketers fall into the former category.
User ID not verified.
Unless the social media posts:
A. Moves Product.
B. Retain existing customers.
It is an exercise in futility.
User ID not verified.