-
Opinion | Features
My memo to your boss
So let me guess?
You really want to come to Mumbrella360, but you’ve got to justify the time and cost to your boss?
Good news! I think I can help.
Woz not great
In this guest post Tony Prysten argues that the thousand dollar price of seeing out-of-touch Apple co-founder Steve Wozniack on his Australian tour was a waste of money.
This week, for the cost of two iPads (yep, two) I went to the Woz Live conference in Melbourne. I was not impressed.
What the hell is transmedia?
From advertising campaigns to online video series, the term ‘transmedia’ gets quite the work out. But what does it actually mean? Cathie McGinn trawls the media landscape for a definitive definition.
Transmedia, all media and multiplatform are terms often used interchangeably when referencing modern storytelling techniques. Yet, depending who you speak to, there are distinct differences between them.
According to industry experts Encore spoke to, the key elements that define transmedia can be summarised as follows: platform, time, audience, adaptation, and creative collaboration.
Innovation is the remedy for the ailing magazine industry
With magazine circulations plummeting, FHM closing and rumours rife on future ownership of ACP Magazines, Paul Merrill says the only way forward is launching new titles.Eight years ago in the UK, nearly a quarter of all magazine sales came from magazines that were less than four years old. In Australia, the figure was slightly lower, but still significant. Today, the situation is very different. For a start there are so few new magazines. Yes, Masterchef briefly flared, and Top Gear made an initial impact. But Grazia and Alpha fizzled, and now ACP has shelved their plans to launch Elle.
More than a game: broadcasting the Olympics
The 2012 London Olympics will be the biggest televised sporting event of our time. Brooke Hemphill discovers the logistical challenges and technical requirements of producing the event.
From July 27 to August 12, the Australian media will go sport crazy as the Games of the XXX Olympiad, aka the 2012 London Summer Olympics, unfold. The games will be the most televised sporting event of our time as broadcasters look to master every manner of technology at their disposal.
The Voice - Australia's best example yet of social TV
In this guest post, Sputnik’s Rodd Messent has a theory on why audiences have taken to The Voice .I am an addict of Channel Nine’s hit show The Voice. Such is the extent of my addiction I seriously think my housemate might kick me out of our apartment for the semi-frenzied yelling and tweeting that ensues in our lounge room each time the show airs.It’s the first time in almost three years that such disagreement has resulted in less than civil behaviour towards one another, and it’s made me think it might be a microcosm of the large volume of online debate about the show and, correspondingly, an explanation for its success as a social TV experience.Why brands are the US Army - and culture jammers are the Viet Cong
In this guest posting, Dave Burgess, who painted ‘No War’ on the Sydney Opera House, claims that ‘amoral’ advertisers have copied his idea.
Culture jamming is a 28-year-old term coined by the San Francisco-based band Negativland, who declared that the ‘Studio for the cultural jammer is the world at large’.
Branded content is dead. Long live branded content
In this guest posting, Anthony Freedman argues why branded content is making a comeback.
A few short years ago, probably concurrent with the advent of the PVR, a new term emerged within the marketing communications industry; branded content. This was really synonymous with advertiser funded TV shows where programming was created by brands and deals struck with networks to broadcast them.
There were varying degrees of success with this model.
Shock advertising: 30 ads that would give Australia's ad watchdog a coronary
Is shock an underused weapon in Australian advertising, asks Robin HicksToday, Sydney agency The Cabana Boys used an image of a mouth sewn together to shock people with the idea that problem gamblers lie to conceal their habit. Is it the most disturbing image ever? No. Will it get banned by the Advertising Standards Bureau? No. But it did make me wonder why shock is not used more often in Australia – and not just by charities and government bodies. (WARNING: NSFW)
The making of ratings blockbuster The Voice
Jason Mountney goes on the set of Channel Nine’s talent search series, The Voice, to see how the format, based on an international franchise, has come together. What ingredients have gone into making this certified hit that’s rated more than two million viewers on three consecutive nights?
Mike Goldman has one of the toughest jobs on the set of the Nine network’s new talent show, The Voice. He not only has to narrate the show, but also keep the audience from losing their enthusiasm as they realise shooting TV programs takes a lot longer than the one-hour bursts they see in their lounge rooms. A lot longer.
Nine problems stopping The Global Mail from getting an audience
While it’s a shame The Global Mail has failed to make an impact on the media landscape, the signs have been there for some time.I love the concept of a well resourced, philanthropically-funded independent news site. Anywhere in the world, that’s a rare and wonderful thing. In Australia even more so. So I hope that Grame Wood gets to see his investment make a difference.
And I have no inside info on whether Monica Attard’s sudden departure is linked to the site’s failure to find an audience so far.
Regardless, here are nine areas they can easily start to address:
Journalism’s new model?
Does the launch of philanthropically funded news site The Global Mail signal a new era for journalism or is the model destined to be a passing fad, asks Cathie McGinn in this article first published in Encore magazine.With little fanfare, philanthropically funded news site The Global Mail launched in February this year.
The online-only title received a generous five-year funding commitment from businessman Graeme Wood, founder of accommodation website wotif.com, who donated $15million.
Five things that make a great suit
In this guest posting, Gareth Collins argues that the role of a great account manager is to make the work betterI’m surprised at how many suits I meet who don’t know their role in the advertising business. The question ‘what does an advertising account manager or director do?’ is frequently met with answers such as project manager, relationship manager, plate spinner or go between … and those are the nice ones.
Success is judged on the ability to manage a process, be strong administratively and get stuff done. And while a good suit needs to do all of these things brilliantly, if these are the traits that define a great suit, then I’m in the wrong job.
What the hell is transmedia?
From advertising campaigns to online video series, the term ‘transmedia’ gets quite the work out. But what does it actually mean? Cathie McGinn trawls the media landscape for a definitive definition.
Transmedia, all media and multiplatform are terms often used interchangeably when referencing modern storytelling techniques. Yet, depending who you speak to, there are distinct differences between them.
The top seven...most patronising pieces of communication
Sometimes brands have big ideas. Sometimes marketers get so caught up with a grandiose idea that instead of finding engaging ways to sell breakfast cereal, they start to believe their own rhetoric. And sometimes it’s just lazy marketing. Here are my top seven inadvertently patronising pieces of communication…
1) Last night thousands of women gathered in Sydney’s Centennial Park to take part in She Runs the Night, an event created by Nike.
Men and sanitary products – a no go zone
Do ads for feminine hygiene products featuring idiotic men really work?
I was asking myself this question as I was watching the soon-to-be launched TV ad for SCA Hygiene’s Libra Invisible pads.
My initial thought was: Why? What do men have to do with what sanitary product women use during that time of the month?
And what stupid man would stick a pad on his face and all over his body and pretend he’s a ninja warrior?
Now, this is nothing new in Libra’s advertising. Some may recall an ad a couple of years ago for Libra tampons where a guy goes into a supermarket to buy a box of tampons for his partner. He decides on the size and type of tampon to buy based on the size of his erm, package.
Then there was another ad featuring a guy (who incidentally and totally unrelated is Alex O’Loughlin, the lead actor in US Vampire drama Moonlight) using his girlfriend’s tampons as a toy for their kitten.
To be fair, this latest effort for Libra Invisible pads is not one of the worst ads I’ve seen in recent times.
My gripe has got nothing to do with the execution. I’m just more perplexed at how the brand and its agency Clemenger landed on this particular strategy.
It surely isn’t just to raise a laugh in order to boost brand awareness – Libra is already the market leader in the pad category with over 50 per cent share, and second in tampons with around 28 per cent share, according to industry figures. So are these ads more skewed towards driving even more sales?
Hey, if there is evidence that the ads have progressively helped SCA grow its share over the years, then clearly I’m in the minority. But could someone at SCA Hygiene shed some light on this and please explain?
Camille Alarcon
February 19th, 2010 at 4:01 pm
-
-
Follow Us
-
Email Newsletter
Latest Jobs- Digital Performance Manager (PPC) – iProspect Sydney – immediate start - Walsh Bay, Sydney
- Client Services Director - Melbourne
- Client Service Director - Melbourne
- PR Senior Account Manager - Travel/Tourism - Sydney
- Qualitative Apprentice – Rare trainee level role - Melbourne
- Qualitative Apprentice – Rare trainee level role - Sydney
- Content Editor - Sydney CBD
- Digital Account Manager - Sydney
- Account Manager - Design - Melbourne - South
- Series Producer - Pyrmont
Comments
19 Feb 10
4:16 pm
Generally speaking and being a girl myself, its an obvious fact to me that girls seek the approval of boys – especially at a young age. To shine such positive light (humor) on a topic we refuse to talk about (with boys) – due to the cringe factor associated with it – helps with brand image and also in hope of putting it out there to our male counterparts – hopefully make such a “taboo” subject – less “cringy”.
19 Feb 10
4:40 pm
I’ve always wondered about the strategy behind for ads for pads and tampons.When I’m at the supermarket, trying to buy a pack of pads or tampons, I feel absolutely bamboozled by the array of different products before me. Small-fit, super, no wings, extra absorbent, night pads anyone? Generally this excess choice means I just pick a brand I’m familiar with, or the pack with the best packaging, and be done with the whole nightmare. So it must really just come down to brand awareness.
19 Feb 10
4:49 pm
Definitely agree with the brand awareness factor as well…
19 Feb 10
5:01 pm
I’m not sure a different strategy would really work? Blue liquid? Technological, no leak advances?
Humour/empathy makes me pay attention to what I would class as a rather mundane, grudge purchase. The ‘super’ package ad still makes me laugh even though I would never send my partner out to buy my sanitary products. Ninja – not so much. The beaver one was also good – no stupid men in that one I don’t think? I’d say it’s straight up brand awareness so you recall instore.
My purchase decision is usually made instore – what do I need, what has worked for me in the past, is the packaging discreet and practical rather than the ‘bright colours’ that scream ‘I’m on my period’ (for this reason, I do not use Libra tampons). Once I find a product/s I’m happy with, I’m pretty loyal because I cannot be bothered spending ages thinking about it.
Also, just on Wilora’s comment re: male approval – I’m not sure about this. When you are making the all important decision about what to buy when you first start your period, I’d suggest you’re more likely to discuss it with your friends and your mum (with your friends probably having more influence than your mum). I would guess, generally speaking, that you stay with the same brand as long as the line continues to cater for your changing needs – mini, regular, super, night time, maternity etc etc – and that’s why it’s important to lock you in at a young age….
I’d be interested to know what kind of research there is on switching brands? I’ve bought maybe four different brands (Tampax, Whisper, Du Jour, Libra for pads) in my life ….do other people switch or are you loyal?
19 Feb 10
5:29 pm
how is this any less horrific than the U by Kotex Platinum launch last year with all the naked women claiming to use it because it offers a “touch of luxury” during that time of the month?
at least these ones are vaguely amusing.
19 Feb 10
6:37 pm
Where do I begin? I guess first of all Kristen I have to agree with you on two of your main points: 1) Brand Awareness and 2) It is important to lock in consumers at a young age (loyalty – tend to stick with a brand that works). All 2 of the 3 commercials are focusing on tampons – so for argument sake I’m going to rip pads out of the equation, plus I don’t use pads – so I can’t speak from experience.
Tampons in a sense all serve the same purpose – to plug. I have tried a variety of brands – due to my constant travels – I am forced to switch, as different countries don’t carry the same brands. But in the end a tampon is still a tampon – the only thing you need to work out is if u need mini, regular or super and that comes with age and trial. Therefore it seems to me that the final purchase decision a consumer makes comes down to – brand awareness and brand personification.
As a “young” female brand personification speaks with a much louder voice than product benefits. Also brand awareness plays a big part in the decision making process and as you say Kristen “humor” helps you pay attention, therefore breaking through clutter. I’m not suggesting that this is the only approach a company should take when coming up with their marketing strategy but it definitely helps.
To me these commercials are humorous but take a carefree, simple and light hearted approach. Just like the decision to buy a tampon should be – carefree, simple and light hearted. I think these commercials actually shine a positive light on such a “taboo” subject – changing perceptions in society. It makes period “a part of life” thing, rather than – it happens lets conceal it – here’s product benefits. Too much information can be overwhelming and scary, young girls don’t want to think about these things. By making the tampon “a part of life” thing it gives the brand a face and a personality – something both girls and boys can associate with.
To me these ads are about increasing comfort levels with the brand, the product and the subject itself. I think it’s a good thing. I don’t think it should be the only method of advertising used, but I do think it is beneficial in order to create a brand personality – which all brands (not just tampons) should endeavor to have.
21 Feb 10
12:14 pm
I am your average consumer and have nothing to do with marketing career-wise at the moment (although have worked in radio presenting and advertising many moons ago) and my husband and I have just watched the ad for the first time.
We thought it was hilarious! Both of us laughed and I nearly had tears in my eyes, prompting me to go online and find the manufacturer to tell them how good we thought it was, which now find me here.
Wilora, I think you are spot on and even after being married to my husband for the past 15 years (I am 33 and he is 38) he still won’t go to the supermarket to buy me sanitary products, but if ads like these can help change his mind I am all for it! (I know it is not the intent of the ad, to have men buy the product, but lifts the comfort level of them knowing that women have these things every month and it’s natural)
Bottom line, bloody funny ad and congrats to the makers
22 Feb 10
12:11 pm
Thanks for that “average consumer” viewpoint Melissa. How is St Leonards today?
22 Feb 10
12:37 pm
Thank god we’re allowed to try to be funny now.
Not so long ago when creating a TVC for FemHygine, a leading client wouldn’t allow dogs, red garments, men, humour … and a whole bunch of other stuff.
Oh, and the marketing director couldn’t even utter the word ‘period’. He was allowed to, he just couldn’t get the word out.
The category was quite surreal. It’s actually come a long way.
22 Feb 10
1:02 pm
Hi Jason,
Not sure what the St Leonards comment is about (maybe I am being blonde or something) but I work for a French Oil and Gas Company in Perth, Western Australia. If you would liek verification of my “averageness” please let me know – I’d be happy to oblige.
22 Feb 10
1:36 pm
Terribly lame
22 Feb 10
1:59 pm
When I originally saw that Alex O’Loughlin Libra spot, all I could imagine is that woman saying, “that’s not what I meant when I said they were for my pussy…”
22 Feb 10
2:16 pm
Well done Clems on getting all of your team off their clients work and on to this blog so they can defend what is lame, lame, lame.
Looks like a pitch is in the air after another stinker for Libra.
22 Feb 10
2:19 pm
I agree with wilora (in part) about brand awareness and shaking off old taboos. For me these ads work because they’re witty, creative and harmless. And they do what an ad is supposed to do–tell me what the product is and whose brand it is–but best of all, there’s no ridiculous blue liquid or furry animals in sight! (I mean, beavers? seriously? why buy into such a male-oriented image?).
More ads like this on telly and we’ll all be happy.
22 Feb 10
4:26 pm
Thank god we have moved from our obsession with wearing white in advertising while having our period at the beach!
22 Feb 10
5:18 pm
Women find buying sanitary products – pads or tampons – a bit of a pain and slightly embarrassing when they scream “i have my period” as noted by someone above. Fact.
But we have to do it, so we do.
So surely these ads are just aimed at breaking down some of the taboos for the guys sent out to buy their girlfriend’s tampons – they are less likely to scurry past ‘that aisle’ and claim to have never seen it? Perhaps?
Still find them quite annoying though.
22 Feb 10
5:23 pm
@Anonymous I’m just me…
Recent marketing/media/multimedia graduate, who’s owned an events/promo company for 3 years now, just got into AWARD school melbs/perth (chose perth), trying to keep up with the big bad advertising world – whilst remaining cynical and opinionated to keep my mind fresh. Side lines are for pussy’s (sorry couldnt help myself
). I find it helps me define, refine my thoughts and processes. Don’t believe me check my blog… 
if U didnt get it… I have NOTHING to do with clems
p.s. commercial is good…. – brand awareness – subject matter/taboo + personification (in my limited opinion)
p.s.s. you sound upset… warm milk and cookies always make everything better for me – try it!
23 Feb 10
11:53 am
And here we see another idiot male playing with fem hygine products. 1 who would do this? 2 Why is it such a taboo subject? Women have a period every month get over it. Why can’t there be an ad where the guy actually goes to the supermarket get her chocolate, ice cream and (insert hygine product name here) and show an understanding side that the girl might feel like shit and cramped. I always used to buy naprogesic and tampons for my ex then make her a hot water bottle, no big deal and the checkout chick knew they weren’t for me. This is neither funny, cleaver nor effective it adds to the stereotypical idiot male who doens’t understand his partner.
23 Feb 10
3:53 pm
Leave us idiot men alone Libra!
23 Feb 10
5:14 pm
I usually hate the ads they run for sanitary products – the Beaver one being the worse. But I saw the ad everyone here is talking about for the first time last night and laughed my arse off!!! It reminded me of when we were a lot younger and used to make things to play with out of house hold bits and pieces. I also liked the tampon ad that had the guy throwing them out for the cat to chase while the girl was wondering where they had all gone. Who cares if they use a male in the ad? It is meant to catch the viewers attention in a short gap in between the show you are watching, not to mention in between the flicking of the remote control to avoid the ads. Is it going to make me rush out and buy them? Well no, but hey, it will give me a giggle every time I see it, and with the monthly Aunty Flo being nothing but a pain in the backside it is nice to see a funny side to it all.
Oh, and Jason’s comment to Melissa re St Leonards – maybe you should put one of those pads over your mouth to stop you dribbing crap!!
23 Feb 10
11:43 pm
My husband came home from work today and when we saw the ad on tv tonight laughed again and informed me that the group of 16 grown professional men he was on a training course with today were standing around pretending to be the bloke in the ad deflecting laser beams with the pads (minus the pads of course!)….personally, I reckon it’s working.
25 Feb 10
3:27 pm
They are definitely pointless, any teenage girl would cringe at having to watch any tampon/pad ad on TV, especially if amongst the company of other family members including brothers, fathers etc. And any older female made her choice up years ago & it was more than likely on packaging & comfort.
2 Mar 10
1:52 pm
As a man, I’ll have to think twice about running a late night shopping errand for the Libra invisibles or similar now – I’d prefer not being (falsely) accused of picking up some “ninja accessories” (because I’m such an idiot male, why else would I be buying them?).
2 Mar 10
11:08 pm
I’m sorry but every time I watch it I think it’s hilarious…I love it!
I’d even consider buying them so the strategy must be working.
3 Mar 10
8:14 am
I’ve seen these ads and don’t have a strong opinion either way. But having said that I didn’t remember the brand until I read this piece, so I guess it didn’t really work for me.
5 Mar 10
2:20 pm
I find the hypocrisy appalling. If an ad showed “stupid” women not understanding how to do something manly, it would be front page news. Women fought for equality for so long. And now they’re perfectly happy to accept advertising that stereotypes men as idiots. We don’t need to belittle men to sell a women’s product. Just as we don’t need to belittle women to sell a men’s product. I, for one, am sick of it.
6 Mar 10
12:24 am
It may be stupid but this ad is memorable. There’s another one on air where the girl is rushing around trying to organise a dinner party and things are not going her way but ‘at least she can rely on her pad.’ I have no idea what brand it’s for. Enough said.
8 Mar 10
1:48 pm
Quite possibly the worst possible ad on television right now. Humour? No. Representing males as stupid twats? Yes. I can’t imagine a single guy who I know, be it family, friends, colleagues – who would be bored enough to stick sanitary pads on their body to pretend to be a superhero!!!
10 Mar 10
2:44 pm
I’m a girl and I couldn’t agree more with Disgruntled Man and WhatHappenedToCreativity.
I HATE this ad. I think it’s stupid, emasculating, irrelevant and cringe-worthy. It definitely discourages me from buying this product.
Having said that, I work with people who think it’s really funny.
It reminds me of the ad for another product where the guy is sitting on the girls bed looking at her pad and asks her what it is. I don’t know a single male alive over the age of 14 who wouldn’t know what the hell a pad/tampon was.
Is it really necessary to include men in advertising this type of product?
What I would really like to see is an ad asking the Govt. why we still pay a GST on sanitary products – hardly a luxury item.
10 Mar 10
7:00 pm
I did have to ask (and I am glad someone else did!); what the hell is the point of those ads?! Not even funny, and with sanitary products the price they are, if my boyfriend used them as “accessories”, I’d have conniptions. No evidence of “truth in advertising” in that campaign!!!
10 Mar 10
9:35 pm
8,000 fans think this ad rocks! Go Libra
http://www.facebook.com/#!/pag.....554?ref=nf
15 Mar 10
2:36 pm
I usually hate womens hygiene ads but i though this was very funny. I actually unmute the ad to listen to the state of the art sound effects. Love the ad.
15 Mar 10
4:25 pm
My housemate and I love the invisible ad. I have to agree with the earlier posters (morris & Kirstin) talking about how it probably does come down to brand awareness, because generally ads that show leakages/blue liquid or talk bout “white skirt days” just make me cringe.
Although we want something that is reliable i don’t think women really need to be reminded of how gross having your period is. I mean, cmon, a pad is another form of a nappy for grown people.
So, go humor. Most sanitary items do the same thing, and there haven’t been that many actual improvements over the years, so I think it works.
15 Mar 10
4:28 pm
Also, @SisP – I believe Coles had a campaign where they removed GST from sanitary products. Not sure if they are still doing this? But i thought it was pretty clever.
15 Mar 10
4:29 pm
By itself, I think the ad has some humour. But it’s not by itself. It’s one part of a regular barrage of “men are stupid” spots. I agree with Disgruntled Man. If we portrayed women the same way, the spots would be pulled in a minute.
16 Mar 10
3:25 am
It’s a pretty harmless way of helping to defuse the discomfort some people feel about seeing ads for personal hygiene products on television. A lot of people tune out commercials, at least this might give them a laugh.
16 Mar 10
3:56 pm
To me (and i’m just putting my desired spin on it) these ads play to the fact that at that time of the month when I’m in a really bad mood, I want to laugh AT (not with) someone and it’s probably going to be my boyfriend if it’s not that guy sticking pads all over himself. Definitely wouldn’t make me buy that brand but may lighten my mood. Defo wouldn’t send my boy out to buy my pads!! Poor things.
I wish someone would come up with a completely catty, carcastic campagin that really plays up to how we feel at that time of the month. Then they’d be hitting the nail on the head, I’d be right into that brand. Did anyone see that letter that was doing the rounds on email recently about a US pad campaign and the consumer backlash against it, now if you check the campaign website out and imagine it was all written tongue in cheek that would do the trick for moi!
The campaign: http://www.beinggirl.com/en_US...../index.jsp
The consumer response: http://wendiaarons.com/2007/03.....ysnet.html (be sure and read the comments section)
Heeelarious! Wish me a happy period I dare ya..
18 Mar 10
5:27 pm
I’ve worked on the SanPro category for a number of years now and all of the brands seem to occupy a similar space – “girl power”, “confidence”, “freedom”, “it’s a girl thing”.
It seems that Libra’s position is something along the lines of “guys just don’t get it”.
All of these campaigns are so same-samey. I don’t think consumers can really differentiate one brand of tampon from the other. Particularly when the category sticks to this formula.
I was well impressed with the Kotex* approach (Beaver) – polarising, yet effective. It recognised that women can have a sense of humour too. It broke free from the category norms & allowed the brand to stand out from the others. And they followed this through all the way to shelf (bright fluoro/black packaging vs. pastel norm).
*Note – this was not my campaign & I’ve never worked with this client.
Trackbacks/Pingbacks