Ignore the hype – transparency is a non-issue
The industry has dropped its bundle and is shrieking about transparency , says Simon Larcey, but that is far from digital advertising’s biggest problem. In this guest post, he explains where the blame for programmatic’s underperformance really lies.
When programmatic came blazing onto the scene, it was hailed as a silver bullet – it would slash agency overheads, ensure clients cut-through to the audience they want, no matter how specific, and virtually single-handedly end the issue of wastage.
The problem is, virtually nothing is perfect straight out of the gate, and so it’s proven for programmatic.
But instead of addressing the issue – that programmatic isn’t getting the return on investment it promised – we’ve dropped our bundle and started shrieking about transparency.
Programmatic isn’t the problem, it is how it is being used. Too much focus is on driving down the cost of CPMs rather than looking at performance metrics or investing in the premium inventory that exists.
Marketers have come to view trading desks as a low cost channel but herein lies the problem because its success is defined by basic cost and reach metrics rather than metrics that relate to campaign performance or business outcomes.
You get what you pay for and low cost in media rarely equates to good value. There’s so much rubbish inventory out there so the level of wastage is high if you look for cheap.
The lack of transparency around agency trading desks merely clouds the performance problem at a time when marketers have been caught asleep at the wheel of digital.
Fixing transparency won’t solve the performance issue, but it will allow marketers to better understand where their investment goes. It should also encourage agencies and other supply chain vendors to be a bit more fair and accountable with client money and the margins they retain.
This could help drive better behaviours and performance.
“But do you honestly believe anyone would really be as bothered about mark-ups if their profits have gone through the roof since they first engaged a given agency?”
Really? If an agency tells me they are charging 10% on media and they are really charging me 50% its a problem.
And it’s fraud.
I agree with both Bob and Nic. Fundamental to any functional relationship is trust. This very basic need is currently not being met by many operators in this area. Until it is met then clients will understandably (and quite rightly) struggle to move beyond this and entertain legitimate discussions on ROI.
Dont care how much money Im making – I want to know how much money is being made off me too. No one wants to look like a fool.
Transparency is a major issue – dont you think!!!!>
@david @nic
Why should agencies inform clients of their margin? Do most companies tell consumers how much a product or service really costs? I haven’t heard an argument yet as to why we clients have this right. And as this article points out, surely the issue is overall perfomance. If an agency makes great margin off of me, then fine. As long as the overall metrics work. Agencies are businesses too, and I want my agency peformig strongly. It becomes an issue if I am lied to about margin, but what gives me the right to ask? Should I then have this expectation across the board?
Transparency shouldn’t be an issue at all. All focus should be on ensuring the clients money is spent in the best possible way. That’s why they employ you. The fact that people are even debating the importance of transparency speaks volumes.
I’m with Nic on this one. Transparency isn’t optional.
I’m a little confused by the ppl in this comment stream who seem to think that Simon was advocating an opaque approach to client relationships. He clearly says multiple times that agencies should not be engaging in dodgy dealings, that agencies who pull the wool over the eyes of their clients (eg by saying they charge 10% when they really charge 50%) should be found out. His argument is that this isn’t the REAL issue. Agencies can be as transparent as they like but if programmatic isn’t getting business results for their clients, then their clients will still be pissed. I repeat … a lack of transparency isn’t good, but mere transparency will NOT solve the woes of programmatic.. Business results will. Great article Simon. Glad to see someone going against the grain with an actual opinion!