Adland should do more to shape the narrative about queer Australia
On International Day Against Homophobia, Transphobia and Biphobia, Blake Mason reflects on being himself in adland, and where to next.
Growing up gay in the Shire in Sydney’s south, I could count the number of times I’d seen a same-sex relationship depicted anywhere in the media. The stigma and fear around AIDS in the 80s had gripped my parents’ generation and this message – that being anything other than heterosexual was dangerous – permeated through to impressionable young people like me.
Fast forward 15 or 20 years and society is a lot more accepting of others’ sexualities. The 2017 same sex marriage vote showed overwhelmingly that Australians believe the rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans, queer and intersex (LGBTQI) people should be protected. Frustratingly, the stomping ground of my youth was still in the ‘no’ camp.
But, of course, the battle for recognition doesn’t end there. Despite anti-discrimination laws, studies have shown that gay men in Australia are paid, on average, 20% less than their straight counterparts. Gay men also face greater barriers to promotion and career advancement than heterosexual men, resulting in slower wage growth. When I was in my mid-twenties, I remember putting together my 10 year plan, but it took me an additional five years to get where I wanted to be. I believe this is due – at least in part – to my perception that the environment I was working in didn’t allow me to bring my whole self to work. While I never hid my sexuality, according to 2014 research from the Australian Human Rights Commission, 40% of LGBTQI people do hide their sexuality at work for fear of discrimination. So does hiding your sexuality mean you’ll have a greater chance to succeed? Or does the suppression of who you are stifle your opportunities to do great things? I believe it’s the latter.
The benefits of bringing your full self to work – or rather, the negative impact on productivity and mental health of not doing so – has been well documented in recent years. Having an open and diverse workplace benefits everyone. Thankfully, we are seeing more of a focus on diversity and inclusion, and an emphasis on people over profit.
Today, we celebrate International Day Against Homophobia, Transphobia and Biphobia (IDAHOBIT). We remember the decriminalisation of homosexuality. And we recognise that we, as communicators, have a crucial role to play in ensuring the faces and voices of all Australians are seen and heard.
Collectively, we influence big brands and media. We are in a position to put forward talent. We should ensure that it’s diverse talent, not just within the queer space but also from other minority groups.
Millennials (those of us aged 23-38 in 2019) make up nearly a third of Australia’s population, and are set to make up three quarters of the Australian workforce by 2025. Whether Australians like it or not, the interests and values of this generation will shape the future of the Australian economy. In the most recent Deloitte Millennial Survey, fewer than half of millennials believe businesses behave ethically (45% in 2018 vs 75% in 2017). Globally, 69% of millennial employees who think their senior management teams are diverse also think their working environments are motivating and stimulating. And 78% of millennials who say their top teams are diverse report their organisations are generating strong profits.
Today, I’m lucky enough to work in a company that celebrates diversity. I can honestly say we can all bring our authentic selves to work, and we seek out opportunities to promote and encourage education of other people’s individuality. As a result, our people perform better, we generate better ideas for our clients, and produce better outcomes. It also means we are able to talk with first hand authenticity about the role CSR plays in ensuring a brand’s success.
Pockets of success exist in adland – in PR, we see a strong representation of female leaders, and we’re for the most part proudly flying the rainbow flag – however, more needs to be done across the board. What organisations choose to do will vary depending on their size and the appropriateness of each aspect of diversity in their business. It could be as simple as throwing a lunch for NAIDOC week using Indigenous caterers and having a yarn with staff. It could be ensuring the organisation has gender quotas and conducts a pay parity review with the Workplace Gender Equality Agency. It could be broadening your reach of talent to ensure there’s stronger representation of race and disability in media.
Whatever you do, it simply needs be done with respect and authenticity. Start the conversation in that state of mind and you can’t go wrong.
Blake Mason is an Account Director at N2N Communications and leads Diversity & Inclusion for Herd MSL
I disagree on your view that hiding your sexuality doesn’t mean you’ll have a greater chance to succeed in Adland.
I’m gay and proud, but when faced with a group of straight men on the exec level they don’t feel comfortable with gay people, in fact I was kept out of pitch presentation with an idea I came up with because ‘‘the straight client on the car brand won’t feel comfortable with a gay person on his straight car brand’’ direct quote. My idea went on to win the pitch, the straight guy and girl sent in to represent the agency later lead the account, followed by a promotion executing my concepts.
I remained the most awarded senior creative, bringing in more business than any other team and yet never got a promotion. I’m good and got overlooked because of my sexuality and straight execs not feeling comfortable having a camp guy leading brands or having a title.
This is not an isolated incident in Australia and the world, I’ve had loads of gay friends experiencing this. Being gay currently means you get complimented for your style and how good your hair looks or proudly shown some rainbow flag idea the straight team has come up with for awards. That’s NOT inclusion. Inclusion looks like equal pay, getting promotions we deserve having representation at exec levels.
Now we are also getting blanketed with the ‘Too many men’ in agencies, now recruiters and agencies are overlooking gay men, because they don’t understand how being gay has affected our careers too. Diversity is gay of BOTH sexes, races, people with disabilities, and of course female.
User ID not verified.
The Shire voted yes, pretty comprehensively. Why would you write the opposite?
User ID not verified.
I don’t see the zeitgeist as having changed one iota since the 70s except that the PC brigade have driven the prejudice underground in more (so called) “enlightened circles”. There is still a certain undercurrent; you can just feel it, even from those professing an “inclusive attitude” (meaning “I know you are different, but I will outwardly pretend otherwise”). So it is still career suicide to declare “gayness”. Most (over 30s) still secretly think that it is a choice and that it can be “cured” by the righteous bigoted religionists and their bloodthirsty “good book”. Of course, amongst the plethora of bogans (and certain “religious” NRL thugs) that we are afflicted with in australia, the prejudice is overt, alive and kicking (quite literally: NRL again). It ain’t gonna change because huge vested money and religious interests demand population growth at any cost. Actually, the pendulum is currently swinging back towards religious (so called) conservatism and Nazi style nationalism. Just look at the US taking away abortion rights and Brunei wanting to stone gays to death. Russia is also strongly going in that direction (their “orthodox religion” is a feudal horror story). Just remember that the Nazis took the lists of self-declared gays in the 1930s in order to send them to the death camps. History *always* repeats. It *can* happen today. As the “good book” says: “There is nothing new under the sun”.
User ID not verified.
“Adland should do more to shape the narrative about queer Australia.”Adland should be doing a sh*t load more to shape the narrative of people with disabilities in Australia – 20% of the population.
If brands want a point of difference with their creative then white, heterosexual, able-bodied talent will not deliver.
User ID not verified.
Not sure Mumbrella didn’t post my comment.
The ‘stomping ground of your youth’ was not in the No camp. It was very much in the Yes camp. Such a lazy untruth makes the rest of this sound very woe is me.
User ID not verified.
Outstanding piece! Well said!
User ID not verified.
Hi William,
This question is singular and not leading to or indicative of my opinion on the matter, but where are you getting your data behind the assertion that “Most (over 30’s) still think that it is a choice and can be cured”?
I find that very hard to believe. If you said “over 60” or “over 70” I might let it slide as anecdotal, but “Over 30” seems like a significant stretch.
User ID not verified.
Hi Steve,
A so-called “hard figure” like that is of course impossible to ascertain as it relies on “self reporting” which is notoriously unreliable. As an indicator, we can look to those put on a pedestal by society as a proxy for generalised “feeling tones” of the masses. I speak specifically of the massively homophobic boofheads (eg. soundcloud.com/vexser/boofheads) of the sporting fields. Then you also have the “blokey” culture of the “troidsmen”. Just try declaring anything but boofiness in those circles! When one is deeply closeted, the covert undercurrents are easily observable (as self-censorship of the analysand is at a low level). And, let’s be honest, most “straight” reporting men (of breeding age) are uncomfortable around a gay male: “does he find me attractive?” They subconsciously find it threatening as it reverses their dominant “hunter” position. Since they cannot/will-not understand anything but their “normal” orientation, and since they subconsciously know that their own orientation is somewhat fluid (especially when young), they secretly see it as a choice which can be changed. I could write a book on this subject. But when you are dealing with social normative (especially religious) prejudices which are not even consciously recognised (but still observable by a third party), then first hand observation of one’s immediate psychological involvement area is the only way of getting an approximate idea of scale. We are currently seeing (previously hidden) undercurrents now coming to the surface with the rise of the so-called “hard right” movement(s). The PC brigade has done great harm by driving the issue(s) underground and stifling honest and open discussion. Russia is a good example of everyone towing the party line but doing completely different things in the shadows. So my “over 30” comment might be conservative.
User ID not verified.
Lisa, you are wrong, sorry.
A good creative has the ability to put themselves in other people’s shoes.
I’m a straight white man. However, there’s not a cell in my body that thinks that ads targeted at me (e.g. a beer ad, a chainsaw ad) couldn’t be made beautifully and compellingly by a queer woman of colour.
And vice-versa.
User ID not verified.
@Lisa, sorry, scrap that – I was wrong. I didn’t read your comment properly.
If I could, I’d delete my comment above.
I realise now you’re talking about talent/models with disabilities being underrepresented in Aussie advertising.
Sorry again.
User ID not verified.
Lisa – You should write that article.
This is about something different though.
Rights aren’t like cake. There isn’t a finite amount of them and if I have a slice you can’t.
Everyone gets to have rights
User ID not verified.