Three uncomfortable truths about brand purpose
Brand purpose has been one of the buzz marketing phrases of 2014 with experts urging companies to stand for something more than profits. Here Benjamin Harrison argues very few brands can pull it off.
If only measured in articles, books, agencies and events espousing brand purpose – the idea driving brands through an understanding of ‘why we exist beyond making money’ or the ‘noble end’, then 2014 has been its peak year to date.
It’s also the year that Chipotle – the famously purpose-led fast food chain – reported explosive 19.8 per cent same-store sales growth in the US. By comparison, McDonald’s – a one-time stakeholder of the brand – posted a 3.3 per cent drop in the same period.
Steve Ells, Chipotle’s charismatic founder, once said “our performance is rooted in our long term vision to change the way people think about and eat fast food”.
It seems the proof is in the organic pinto. But here are three hard truths about purpose we can learn from the Chipotle story.
1. Purpose can be expressed, not invented (or: sorry, you don’t actually have a higher purpose)
Chipotle founder Steve Ells’ purpose epiphany happened when he discovered how pigs where raised in the US. What began as a personal mission become a compelling brand purpose around ‘cultivating a better world’.
It’s deeply troubling when consultants say they’ve ‘created’ a brand purpose for a client. A purpose can be expressed, articulated and activated, but can’t be conjured out of thin air or transplanted onto an orgnaisation.
The hard truth is that not every organisation has a higher purpose above making money. The mistaken belief that every business can be purpose-led has resulted in a swathe of generic and empty faux-purposes: ‘making the world better a smile at a time’, ‘inspiring humanity’ and ‘making a difference’.
That is not a purpose that will drive preference, galvanise your people or differentiate your business.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lUtnas5ScSE
2. Purpose takes relentless proof (or: no, it not enough to put purpose at the top of your brand pyramid)
Chipotle is famous for its content: the Scarecrow and Back to the Start videos, and ‘Farmed and Dangerous’, an original comedy series highlighting problems in the food industry.
Easy, right? Just make brilliant brand content that expresses the big idea behind your purpose and the rest will follow. The hard truth is that it isn’t an easy approach. Purpose requires relentless proofing to keep consumers reminded of your big mission.
For Chipotle, that proof has includes its Cultivate festivals of food, ideas and music, the “Cultivating Thought” initiative where writers like Toni Morrison and Malcolm Gladwell write two-minute reads on packaging. Proof includes constant menu innovation in line with the brand promise – from organic beans to locally grown Californian lettuce.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMfSGt6rHos
3. Purpose is a premiumisation strategy (or: surprise surprise, it all comes back to profits at the end)
Chipotle has a problem: food costs are going up. This year food costs were 34.3 per cent of revenue, an increase of 70 basis points, driven by increased prices for beef, avocados and dairy.
The good news is that people are prepared to pay a premium for a strong purpose. And by people, we mean Millennials.
A couple of days ago, Steve Ells told USA today: “Millennials are turning away from traditional fast food in favour of better food. They are willing to pay more for something they recognise as better.”
If purpose can premiumise, the strategy works particularly well for businesses targeting Millennials: the demographic most likely to make values-based decisions about brands.
Purpose isn’t a silver bullet for every brand. It’s something inherent in a few organisations that are truly motivated to change the world for the better, and are actually doing it.
Benjamin Harrison is strategy director of RE.
This fake-authenticity is useful as a marketing tactic but that’s all it is.
It helps resolve a particular cognitive dissonance.
Now you can be a do-gooder and still consume – millennials FTW!
Purpose/authenticity is the new cool, the status-oriented nature of the activity remains the same.
‘people are prepared to pay a premium for a strong purpose’ – and for the status that comes with it.
I’m off for some $10 arisanal toast.
User ID not verified.
Purpose should be about making things happen inside an organisation, not merely the positioning of its offer to the market. That’s where I think this article misses a trick.
All corporate brands should have a purpose.
Purpose can help employees connect emotionally to an organisation and to their work. It can define certain operational imperatives. It can compel certain behaviours and modes of working. And ultimately all of these things will bear fruit for customers as employees full of purpose delivers great outcomes whether they’re product designers, marketers or customer service operators.
Agree that purpose is best not ‘invented’ by an agency but residual in an organisation or at least in its CEO’s vision. If it isn’t tapping into something authentic it won’t work.
User ID not verified.
Good concise article.
User ID not verified.
Interesting. ANU’s recent ESG decision to offload investments relying on fossils fuels sits in contrast to reports that it has the highest carbon footprint of the main Australian universities.
In order for Brand Purpose to be valid, should not every single aspect of a business’ existence conform to a completely ‘fault-free’ set of criteria? Or is it enough to be very visible on a certain Brand Purpose whilst ignoring or failing to attend to other possibly relevant issues? Does Chipotle’s Brand Purpose negate the apparently excessive sodium content of its products?
I think it’s a great marketing ploy for the right product/audience. Your points re: execution of strategy are well-made.
User ID not verified.
A brand’s purpose, if it is to have any value from a brand perspective, must be relevant to the actual product or service. A company suddenly deciding to offsett carbon emissions or donating to charity is great, but hardly sets them apart. Which is why the most successful ones – e.g. Chipotle, Virgin, Bodyshop, Patagonia, Apple, Tesla – tend to have been founded by visionary individuals who makes sure the brand stays on track.
I still think it’s possible for brands to invent a purpose from scratch, it’s just very difficult and most attempts fail miserably. Dove managed to. As did Diesel and Lynx. Purpose doesn’t just have to be about saving the planet. Anything above and beyond the category generic that goes to solve some sort of higher-level problem for people is arguably a purpose, at least from a marketing pov.
User ID not verified.
Brand purpose is only useful if it is something that can be monetised, and it can only be monetised if it is consonant with your consumer’ need that your product benefit delivers on – competitively,uniquely and consistently.
User ID not verified.
I dunno, Neil.
Brands that are widely recognised as the poster boys for ‘purpose’ e.g. Apple, IBM usually identify that revenue is not their primary business driver. They understand that if you get your business focused and aligned in a singular direction, that will lead to better products, better services, better customer loyalty – and bottom line success will follow.
Making money is a fact of life for businesses but it’s perilous to put it at the centre of things. It should be the outcome of what you do, not the starting point.
User ID not verified.
I hear you and feel your pain, tacking on phrases like ‘purpose’ when it is mearly whitewashing, be it by a consultant or a company is painful to witness. But not new news.
It’s all just language.
Call it positioning, USP, DNA, purpose..if there is not a bigger idea than just making money, it becomes hard to find a reason for people to believe or even notice you, let alone want to work for you.
That doesn’t mean companies with a ‘purpose’ won’t mess up – the world is a messy place, or that companies won’t try to bandaid on a meaningful purpose, nothing new there. But it is becoming increasingly difficult to hoodwink people externally.
This is in a climate where Corporations have a primary role to increase shareholder value (ie Make money), challenger brands are nipping at their heels, (and yes often with purpore driven brands) and technology companies are increasingly disrupting traditional models.
It’s complicated. But we choose in the end with our wallets who wins; building a culture that reflects our collective values.
User ID not verified.
So is McDonalds brand purpose to feed people as fast and as cheaply as possible a bad thing?
Or is there some other rhetoric that I’m missing?
User ID not verified.
Maybe I’m old school , but I think its dishonest to start with the premise that businesses exist for some higher purpose than to make money. There are other forms of organisations that occupy this space.
For a business to be successful in making money, they need to cater to different stakeholders – shareholders, employees, customers, suppliers , community and govt.
The primary paymasters are customers – as it is they who pay you for what you are offering. The other stakeholders are enablers. Terms like brand purpose, culture values , credos etc are articulations of strategies to energise / address these stakeholders. Although I don’t like using brand purpose for this – as brand is the primary customer link. A way around this is companies like who have brands separate from corporate name -eg Unilever, P&G etc . Keep them separate , and everyone is clear .
User ID not verified.
I’d like to marry Nick.
To connect with purpose is to connect with an organisations truth and not all companies are ready for that. Its way more than marketing or branding alone, it starts with internal brand building and has a lot to do with leadership culture.
I believe that every business has something unique and relevant to offer the world, by tapping into what that is may mean that they need to undertake massive change in their business, and if they’re willing to put in the hard yards to do so I believe that there will be ever-greater opportunities for their business and their brand.
User ID not verified.