Brandscreen demise a reminder there is no silver bullet in automation
The news Brandscreen has gone into administration proves we are still a long way from getting media automation right argues Matthew Hunt.
I was as surprised as anyone else to hear the news on Friday that one of Australia’s newest independent advertising technology companies, demand side platform (DSP) Brandscreen, had entered into administration.
As the MD of cross channel advertising platform Adconion, I have constantly been hearing that DSPs are meant to be the future of the industry. Exchange based ad trading has been delivering double-digit revenue growth and with aggressive leadership controverting all who challenged the strategy,the outward veneer certainly looked good.
There is no question in my mind that this news signals a critical juncture for the programmatic advertising industry. It does not spell the end of the DSP, but it does signal the first big chink in the armour of the model.
The halo effect is starting to fade, and reality is setting back in after the irrational hype of the past 24 months. But why is this seemingly bulletproof approach to online ad trading starting to show signs of being vulnerable? In my view, the answer is quite straightforward. It wasn’t about the technology; it was actually about the audience all along.
So what does that mean? Whilst technology undoubtedly brings a multitude of benefits, on its own it is not enough.To be successful, most trading desks, publishers and ad networks are beginning to understand that a tech layer in isolation can’t deliver the end result-reaching the right audience in the right channel at the right price.
From what I can see, it is the companies managing media businesses on top of robust technological platforms that are the only ones delivering real sustainable margins. And this is important because it allows a company to reinvest in its technology, it’s partners and it’s people.
Google and to a lesser degree Facebook certainly know this, managing to combine tech, media, data and people to build long-term value for advertisers and publishers.
The technology can be an enabler, but brands don’t care about how advanced your circuitry is. They care about investing to connect with the audience most likely to interact and convert with their product.
This takes more than an algorithm to deliver, especially in such a fragmented media industry.
And it’s not only the technology that can’t survive in a vacuum; genuine scale on a global level is also becoming non-negotiable. Pure tech players have very little room to expand margins, with growth limited to running more inventory and data available across the platform to as many clients as possible. Even at high revenue levels, the cost of engineering and R&D make it difficult to drive profitability unless you can secure market share at scale.
Subsequently low margin ‘software as a service’ solutions can only guarantee a sustainable business model through scaling across multiple international markets. Single market and regional players are always going to have an Achilles heel when looking to compete on a level playing field.
Of course, this means Brandscreen was operating in a far from level playing field and the ability of global companies on the buy and the sell side to collaborate was inevitable.
But when all is said and done, the demise of relative startups such as Brandscreen is a reminder that there is no silver bullet to automating our media future. Technology is an important part, but technology only allows you to more effectively connect with your audience.
It is only when people use this technology to combine media with data that advertisers achieve results at scale through programmatic trading.
Matthew Hunt is the managing director of Adconion Australia
Maybe a new head-shot which didn’t show a massive smiling face next to a story about a company going bust, presumably with a knock-on of people losing their jobs, might have been a good idea.
User ID not verified.
To the writer ‘Unfortunate’… are you kidding? Have a look at all the shots of the other blog writers: they’re smiling. What’s wrong with trying to be/look happy? The writer of this blog provided some interesting observations, and you bag him because he smiles? I’m sure there is no gloating or self-enjoyment implied by Matthew (and I don’t know him) having a smiley mug shot. However, please, Unfortunate, take some time to take in some perspective and comment on the essence of what someone says, not associated trivia. In turn, I’m not attacking whoever you are, rather, just asking you to give more time and thought to someone’s writing efforts, before you press ‘send’. It’s 2014, and hopefully a great year, let’s not allow this site to be as aggressive as other industry sites. Happy New Year, Unfortunate.
User ID not verified.
Matthew…a little thing but please understand the difference between its and it’s.
You’ve used its three times in this sentence but only spelt it correctly once:
“And this is important because it allows a company to reinvest in its technology, it’s partners and it’s people.”
Other than that, a good article on DSPs.
User ID not verified.
Nice one Matt – good article, and I have to agree with Nic, let’s chill-out a little bit. I have known Matt Hunt for years, and he is a pretty smiley guy!
User ID not verified.
The proliferation of ATDs and absence of local data venders undoubtedly contributed to their demise.
User ID not verified.
This advertorial from Adconion misses the point that it’s a business – not a business model – that has failed. Turn announced an additional $80m round of funding this week – something you rarely get from private equity firms when you’re barking up the wrong tree – so this is down to survival of the fittest, nothing more. As this evolution plays out it will be interesting to watch the ad network versus the DSP. My money is on the extinction of the former.
User ID not verified.
Adconian are desperately trying to play catch-up in this space. The growing power of ATDs and the rise of ad-exchange models from Google and Facebook have seen their value diminish considerably. Ironically if they had’ve adopted some kind of independent DSP model and gone to market with it a couple of years ago, they might be sitting pretty right now. Maybe, they could have even partnered with Brandscreen!
User ID not verified.
@ Charles Darwin: The round Turn has raised is a proof point for this article! Only global scale can save DSPs as they operate in a low margin space. And only the strongest can survive (but you should know as the inventor of evolution). Technology is an enabler. You still need strong partners who understand audience buys.
User ID not verified.
Well said Matt, cannot agree more. It’s going to be an interesting year ahead for all of us.
User ID not verified.
Agree with some of the points but I think timing and content is a little self serving. Does the red lever product that’s in your picture still exist? Smart clip, Adconion’s video product has been closed down in most markets. Is that because your tech didn’t deliver? or adconion doesn’t have the talent? The programmatic industrial will continue to grow around the world, but like all industrial there will be some that don’t make it. In a weird way this is a good thing, as with failure we learn. (I mean no disrespect to the people who lost their jobs)
I would be more concerned about ad networks then DSP’s and alike. This new industrial is provide transparent to the market and they are innovating at a very fast rate which benefits the advertisers
User ID not verified.
@ charles darwin. Yes and no. My opinion is that all pure play DSP’s are under competitive pressure from agency trade desks to operate with lean pricing structures. This will only increase as DSPs move away from managed service models to pure self service models. I think this will encourage DSPs to evolve their model so they can make margins on the media they trade in return for providing publishers access to trading desk demand. Regarding Turn’s fund raising, I think this reinforces my point. They are looking to fund their expansion and global scale, which will allow for a sustainable, high volume business. This is great! Regarding ad network vs DSP extinction, I’m not sure this is the point. I’d like to reference the real Charles Darwin who said “it is not the strongest or the most intelligent that will survive, but those who can best manage change”. I think there will be winners and losers on both sides.
User ID not verified.
@captain hindsight: I’m not sure we’re playing catch up but we are certainly as committed as ever to our vision of connecting brands with audiences.
User ID not verified.
@John: The businesses you mention have been important acquisitions that moved our Australian business from a single channel display business in 2007 to the true cross channel business we have in 2014. On a single platform, under a single Adconion brand, we offer display, video, email and social channels which are accessible on all devices. We are proud of our technology and we are respectful of the other companies investing in ad tech that are driving innovation and opportunities within our industry.
User ID not verified.